# Verification of Gyrokinetic codes: theoretical background and applications

## TL;DR

This paper introduces a comprehensive theoretical and numerical framework for verifying gyrokinetic codes, crucial for accurate plasma turbulence modeling in fusion research, by combining variational formulations and benchmark tests.

## Contribution

It presents a novel unified approach using variational methods for theoretical verification and benchmark testing for numerical validation of gyrokinetic codes.

## Key findings

- Established a hierarchy of reduced GK Vlasov-Maxwell equations
- Verified two major GK codes: ORB5 and GENE
- Applied methodology to CYCLONE Base Case scenarios

## Abstract

In fusion plasmas the strong magnetic field allows the fast gyro-motion to be systematically removed from the description of the dynamics, resulting in a considerable model simplification and gain of computational time. Nowadays, the gyrokinetic (GK) codes play a major role in the understanding of the development and the saturation of turbulence and in the prediction of the subsequent transport. Naturally, these codes require thorough verification and validation. Here we present a new and generic theoretical framework and specific numerical applications to test the faithfulness of the implemented models to theory and to verify the domain of applicability of existing GK codes. For a sound verification process, the underlying theoretical GK model and the numerical scheme must be considered at the same time, which has rarely been done and therefore makes this approach pioneering. At the analytical level, the main novelty consists in using advanced mathematical tools such as variational formulation of dynamics for systematization of basic GK code's equations to access the limits of their applicability. The verification of numerical scheme is proposed via the benchmark effort. In this work, specific examples of code verification are presented for two GK codes: the multi-species electromagnetic ORB5 (PIC) and the radially global version of GENE (Eulerian). The proposed methodology can be applied to any existing GK code. We establish a hierarchy of reduced GK Vlasov-Maxwell equations implemented in the ORB5 and GENE codes using the Lagrangian variational formulation. At the computational level, detailed verifications of global electromagnetic test cases developed from the CYCLONE Base Case are considered, including a parametric $\beta$-scan covering the transition from ITG to KBM and the spectral properties at the nominal $\beta$ value.