Smooth contractible threefolds with hyperbolic $\mathbb{G}_{m}$-actions via ps-divisors
Charlie Petitjean

TL;DR
This paper provides an alternative proof of a theorem characterizing smooth contractible affine threefolds with hyperbolic -actions, using polyhedral divisors to generalize previous approaches.
Contribution
It introduces a new proof method employing polyhedral divisors for classifying certain contractible threefolds with -actions.
Findings
Characterization of smooth contractible affine threefolds with hyperbolic -actions
Application of polyhedral divisors to this classification
Alternative proof of Koras and Russell's theorem
Abstract
The aim of this note is to give an alternative proof of a theorem of Koras and Russell, that is, a characterization of smooth contractible affine varieties endowed with a hyperbolic action of the group , using the language of polyhedral divisors developed by Altmann and Hausen as generalization of -divisors.
Peer Reviews
No public reviews on file for this paper yet. If you reviewed it on a platform where reviews are public (OpenReview, ICLR, NeurIPS, ICML), you can paste yours below so the community can read it here.
Videos
No videos yet. Explain this paper in a talk, walkthrough, or lecture? Add one.
Taxonomy
TopicsGeometric and Algebraic Topology · Algebraic Geometry and Number Theory · Advanced Algebra and Geometry
Smooth contractible threefolds with hyperbolic -actions
via ps-divisors
Charlie Petitjean
Instituto de Matemática y Física, Universidad de Talca, Casilla 721, Talca, Chile
Abstract.
The aim of this note is to give an alternative proof of the theorem 4.1 of [KR4], that is, a characterization of smooth contractible affine varieties endowed with a hyperbolic action of the group , using the language of polyhedral divisors developed in [A-H] as generalization of -divisors.
Key words and phrases:
Affine -varieties, Hyperbolic -actions, Koras-Russell threefolds, Exotic spaces
2000 Mathematics Subject Classification:
14L30, 14R05, 14R10
This research was partially supported by project Fondecyt postdoctorado 3160005.
In [KR4], Koras and Russell provided a characterization of smooth contractible affine varieties endowed with a hyperbolic action of the group . This is an important step in the proof of the linearization conjecture in dimension three [KaKMLR]. The conjecture states that every -action on the affine -space is linearizable, that is, up to a conjugation by an automorphism of , we can assume that the action is linear. The case is trivial and corresponds to the simplest toric case, acting on , for the original proof is due to Gutwirth [G], the case is more difficult and obtained after a long series of articles initiated by Kambayashi and Russell [KamR] continued with Koras [KR1, KR2, KR3, KR4] and achieved with the contribution of Kaliman and Makar-Limanov [KaML, KaKMLR]. In higher dimension, that is for , no general results are known.
On the other hand, the case of -action on can be also viewed as the first case of a linearization conjecture of complexity two, that is, algebraic torus actions of dimension acting effectively on . The linearization conjecture of complexity zero corresponds to the toric case and it is true, as the linearization conjecture of complexity one by a result of Białynicki-Birula [BB]. Here, once again, in higher dimension no general results are known.
The purpose is to use a geometrico-combinatorial presentation of normal varieties endowed with an effective algebraic torus action, developed by Altmann and Hausen [A-H] several years after the result of Koras and Russell. This presentation is a generalization of two presentations, the first one is the presentation of affine toric varieties via cones in lattices [CLS] and the second is the presentation of -surfaces via -divisors [De, FZ]. A recollection in our particular case will be made in the section one. The presentation of a smooth affine variety endowed with a hyperbolic action of consists of a pair such that is a normal variety of dimension playing essentially a role of quotient and is a divisor on with particular coefficients attached on each irreducible components. As it can be expected, this presentation is particularly adapted to give a shorter proof of the charactersation given initially by Theorem 4.1 in [KR4], this is realized in section two. We hope that this note serves to clarify and condense existing results in the field and can be the first step for possible generalizations.
1. Hyperbolic -actions on smooth affine varieties
Let be an affine smooth variety endowed with a hyperbolic -action. First, recall that the coordinate ring of is -graded in a natural way by its subspaces of semi-invariants of weight , , for the effective -action on :
[TABLE]
The action is said to be hyperbolic if there is at least one and one such that and are nonzero. In particular is the ring of invariant functions on , thus is the algebraic quotient to the -action on .
Definition 1**.**
The A-H quotient of is the blow-up of with center at the closed subscheme defined by the ideal , where is chosen such that is generated by and .
Remark*.*
If admits a unique fixed point , then the center of the blow-up is supported at the image of by the algebraic quotient morphism .
Definition 2**.**
A segmental divisor on an algebraic variety is a formal finite sum , where are prime Weil divisors on and are closed intervals with rational bounds . Every element determines a map from segmental divisors to the group of Weil -divisors on :
[TABLE]
Definition 3**.**
A *proper-segmental divisor *(ps-divisor) on a variety is a segmental divisor on such that for every , satisfies the following properties:
is a -Cartier divisor on . 2.
is semi-ample, that is, for some , is covered by complements of supports of effective divisors linearly equivalent to . 3.
is big, that is, for some , there exists an effective divisor linearly equivalent to such that is affine.
Definition 4**.**
A variety is said to be semi-projective if its ring of regular functions is finitely generated and is projective over .
Considering a ps-divisor on a semi-projective variety the -graded algebra
[TABLE]
is finitely generated. The associated affine variety is therefore a -variety. In the case of hyperbolic -action, the main theorem of [A-H] can be reformulated as follows:
Theorem 5**.**
For any ps-divisor on a normal semi-projective variety the scheme
[TABLE]
is a normal affine variety of dimension endowed with an effective hyperbolic -action, whose A-H quotient is birationally isomorphic to .
Conversely any normal affine variety endowed with an effective hyperbolic -action is isomorphic to for a suitable ps-divisor on .
A ps-divisor such that can be obtained by the following downgrading (see [A-H, section 11]):
Consider embedded as a -stable subvariety of an affine affine toric variety. The calculation is then reduced to the toric case by considering an embedding in endowed with a linear action of a torus for a sufficiently large . By this way, the inclusion of corresponds to an inclusion of the lattice of one parameter subgroups of in the lattice of one parameter subgroups of . We obtain the exact sequence:
[TABLE]
where is given by the induced action of on (it is the matrix of weights) and is a section of . Let , for , be the first integral vectors of the unidimensional cone generated by the i-th column vector of considered as rays in the lattice . Let be the toric variety, of maximal dimension , determined by the coarsest fan containing all cones generated by subsets of in . Then each corresponds to a -invariant divisor where , for . By [A-H, section 11], contains the A-H quotient of , as sub-variety, and the support of is obtained by restricting the -invariant divisor corresponding to to . The segment associated to the divisor is equal to , it can occur that the segment is a point. If is the affine space endowed with a linear action of , the embedding of as a -stable subvariety of an affine toric variety is reduced to the identity. In this case, the A-H quotient of is itself.
Linear hyperbolic -actions on have been fully characterized by this method, see for instance [L-P]. Let where , and are strictly coprime positive integers, and let where , , are integers such that . Let for and . In the case of linear hyperbolic -actions on , [L-P, Proposition 11] gives:
Proposition 6**.**
Let endowed with a linear hyperbolic -action. Then is the -equivariant cyclic quotient of a variety isomorphic to and such that is equivariantly isomorphic to the -variety with and defined as follows:
is isomorphic to a blow-up of at the origin. 2.
is of the form:
[TABLE]
with , are the strict transforms of the coordinate axes, is the exceptional divisor of and the linear -action on is given by its matrix of weights with , and strictly positive integers.
Let be equivariantly isomorphic to . Then segmental prime divisors occurring in the ps-divisor encode, according to their coefficients, two distinct facts (see [P] and [FZ, Theorem 4.18] ) :
For any such that is reduced to a rational point , the divisor encodes isotropy subgroup of finite order, or equivalently the fact that is the finite cyclic cover of an other -variety having a A-H quotient isomorphic to that of and where does not appear in the the presentation. 2.
For any such that is an interval with non-empty interior, the divisor encodes isotropy subgroup of infinite order, equivalently fixed points.
In particular as we have assumed that admits a unique fixed point, the only divisor whose coefficient is an interval with non-empty interior is the exceptional divisor of the blow-up .
The smoothness of the -threefold can be checked using [L-P, Theorem 7 and proposition 11]:
If is an affine -variety of dimension , then, is smooth if and only if the combinatorial data is locally isomorphic in the étale topology to the combinatorial data of the affine space endowed with a linear -action.
Example**.**
Let endowed with the -action with matrix of weights . Then is equivariantly isomorphic to where is the blow-up of the algebraic quotient with center at the closed subscheme defined by the ideal , the p-s divisor is of the form
[TABLE]
where , are the strict transforms of the coordinates axes and , and is the exceptional divisor of the blow-up .
admits commuting actions of the groups and of square and cubic roots of the unity defined respectively by and . These commute with the -action and has a structure of a -equivariant bi-cyclic cover of with matrix of weights . Applying the main Theorem of [P], is equivariantly isomorphic to . The ring of regular functions of is -graded via the character lattice of and the ring of regular functions of is -graded via a sublattice of index , thus A-H presentation of is obtained considering the same A-H quotient and a multiple of , namely, . The structure of -equivariant bi-cyclic covering implies that the induced action of on is trivial so that . So, only the ps-divisors change as the lattice changes (see [P]). This is illustrated by the following diagram,
[TABLE]
One way to constructs many examples of varieties endowed with hyperbolic -action is the following (see [T, Z]):
Definition 7**.**
Let be a smooth hypersurface defined by the zeros of the polynomial . The hyperbolic modification of is obtained blowing-up the variety with center at the origin and removing the proper transform of . By this way we obtain a variety which is stable for the following hyperbolic -action on , .
Each of these hyperbolic modifications will be characterized by the following A-H presentation: is equivariantly isomorphic to where is the blow-up of with center at the closed subscheme defined by the ideal , and is the exceptional divisor of the blow-up.
Constructions of koras-Russell threefolds and via
segmental divisors
In this section we will consider an approach to the classification given by Koras and Russell using segmental divisors in an étale neighborhood of a fixed point to determine all possibles configurations for the threefolds.
The tangent space of a smooth -variety at the fixed point is an affine three-space with a linear -action. The action is given by and characterized by its matrix of weight .
In [K], Koras proves that if is endowed with an algebraic -action such that the algebraic quotient is of dimension , then the quotient is isomorphic to , where is a finite cyclic group. If a variety has such algebraic quotient by a -action it was said that has quotient as expected for a -action on .
If is endowed with an action of the group of -th roots of the unity commuting with the -action, then its algebraic quotient inherits also of a -action, possibly trivial.
Theorem 8**.**
A smooth, contractible, affine threefolds with a hyperbolic -action, an unique fixed point and an algebraic quotient isomorphic to , where is a finite cyclic group, is determined by the following data:
* A triple of weights with . These define a hyperbolic -action on the tangent space of the fixed point via the matrix weight *
* A triple of positive integers such that .*
* Curves , in satisfying:*
* is defined by an -homogeneous polynomial.*
* *
* and meet normally in and additional points.*
Proof.
Let be an affine three space endowed with a hyperbolic -action, we assume that is equivariantly isomorphic to where the pair is minimal constructed as in section one.
First step: the A-H quotient.
By assumption the fixed point set of is of dimension [math], and by [BB] it is non-empty and connected and therefore reduced to a unique point, . Using the result of [K], the algebraic quotient of by the -action is isomorphic to where is a finite cyclic group. So the A-H quotient of is isomorphic to a blow-up of supported on the image of by the quotient morphism . Since is smooth, it follow from [L-P] that there exists an étale -invariant neighborhood of , which is equivariantly isomorphic to an étale neighborhood of a fixed point in endowed with a linear hyperbolic -action of the form, with . So is isomorphic to the A-H quotient of the previous and determined by the triple of reduced weights .
Considering an embedding of as a -stable subvariety of an affine space endowed with a linear -action, we can always construct a finite cyclic cover along coordinate axes of the ambient space such that the new variety obtained by this finite ramified morphism admits an algebraic quotient isomorphic to the complex plane . By this way and using [P], we can assume that the A-H presentation of is completely determined by that of the cyclic cover and the data of the cyclic group.
Second step: the ps-divisor in an étale neighborhood of the exceptional divisor.
In terms of ps-divisor as is a smooth -variety, the smoothness criterion gives us that there exists , in , an étale neighborhood of the exceptional divisor such that is equivariantly isomorphic to an étale neighborhood of a fixed point in endowed with a linear hyperbolic -action.
Moreover as is smooth in the étale neighborhood of the fixed point, by [L-P], is of the form:
[TABLE]
where Proposition 6 provides the coefficients and the supports of the divisors in the étale neighborhood.
Third step: the number of irreducible component of the support of .
The ps-divisor is completely determined by . Indeed as admits a unique fixed point by the first section, is the unique divisor whose coefficient is an interval with non-empty interior. Now suppose that
[TABLE]
[TABLE]
By the first section, this implies that there exists a -variety such that is an equivariant cyclic cover of along divisors whose images in the algebraic quotient do not intersect the image of the fixed point and thus does not admit a fixed point. This contradicts the assumption and so is equivariantly isomorphic to where is isomorphic to the A-H quotient of an endowed with a hyperbolic linear -action and is of the form:
[TABLE]
where is the exceptional divisor of and , are the strict transform of the supports of two irreducible curves and defined by the zeros of and respectively.
Fourth step: the topology of the support of .
Once again by the smoothness criterion the support of has to be a SNC-divisor, in particular each irreducible component of the divisors is smooth. Moreover using the previous presentation and [P], admits two actions of finite cyclic group and which factorize by the action. In particular can be viewed as a bi-cyclic cover of of order and , and it admits the following presentation:
[TABLE]
Thus we obtain the following tower of threefolds where is equivariantly isomorphic to with a linear -action :
[TABLE]
As is contractible, so are of and by [KrPRa, Theorem B]. These varieties are obtained by two modifications: first a hyperbolic modification of (or respectively) see Definition 7. By this way we obtain two varieties and which are stable for the following hyperbolic -action on , .
The second modification is a cyclic cover of order (or respectively) of along the variety (or respectively). By [Ka, Theorem A], as the varieties and are contractible, the sub-varieties and of have to be -acyclic for almost every , that is the -homology of the point for almost every . By a classical classification result, this is possible if and only if the smooth curves defined by and in are acyclic and so, are two copies of the affine line .
To summarize, every endowed with a hyperbolic -action is characterized by a pair such that . The A-H quotient of is also the A-H quotient of an endowed with a hyperbolic and linear -action. The coefficient of is the same as those used in the presentation of the endowed with a hyperbolic linear -action and the support of is the union of the exceptional divisor, the strict transform of two curves, and , both isomorphic to a line in , given by polynomials of weights , respectively and intersecting normally at the origin and in other points, where .
Now as the algebraic quotient of is not necessarily , it has been shown that there exists a cyclic group of order such that the algebraic quotient is . The tangent space of at the fixed point is an affine three-space with a linear hyperbolic -action given by with , and positive integers. By construction the order of the finite cyclic group can be chosen as to be . The general case is obtained as a quotient of the previous case by the cyclic group. In particular as proved in [P], the two divisor and have to be invariant for the induced (and possibly trivial) action on the A-H quotient, so and are homogeneous for . ∎
All possible varieties that can be built, and that verify the previous Theorem are not necessary . There is a dichotomy, obtained in [KaML], using the additive group action on them, in particular they prove that the one class of varieties obtained by Koras and Russell in [KR4] which are indeed are those which are “obviously” with a linear hyperbolic -action. This corresponds to the case where and are the two coordinate axes in the same coordinate system in Theorem 8. The, remaining varieties are called Koras-Russell threefolds and classified in three types according to the richness of the -actions on them. The A-H presentation of these varieties has been computed in [P].
Example 9**.**
Let be the -variety equivariantly isomorphic to where is the blow-up of with center at the closed subscheme defined by the ideal , the p-s divisor is of the form
[TABLE]
where is the exceptional divisor of the blow-up and , are the strict transforms of and , then is a smooth contractible threefold endowed with an hyperbolic -action but it is not . In particular .
The reference list from the paper itself. Each links out to its DOI / PubMed record.
- 1[A-H] K. Altmann, J. Hausen. Polyhedral divisors and algebraic torus actions. Math. Ann. 334, 557-607 (2006).
- 2[BB] A. Białynicki-Birula. Remarks on the action of an algebraic torus on k n superscript 𝑘 𝑛 k^{n} . II. Bull. Acad. Polon. Sci. Sér. Sci. Math. Astronom. Phys. 15 1967 123–125.
- 3[CLS] D.A Cox, J.B Little, H.K Schenck. Toric varieties. Graduate Studies in Mathematics, 124. American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, 2011.
- 4[FZ] H. Flenner, M. Zaidenberg. Normal affine surfaces with ℂ ∗ superscript ℂ \mathbb{C}^{*} -actions. Osaka J. Math. 40 (2003), no. 4, 981–1009.
- 5[G] A. Gutwirth. The action of an algebraic torus on the affine plane. Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 105 1962 407–414.
- 6[K] M. Koras. A characterization of 𝔸 2 / ℤ a superscript 𝔸 2 subscript ℤ 𝑎 \mathbb{A}^{2}/\mathbb{Z}_{a} . Compositio Math. 87 (1993), no. 3, 241–267.
- 7[Ka] S. Kaliman. Smooth contractible hypersurfaces in ℂ n superscript ℂ 𝑛 \mathbb{C}^{n} and exotic algebraic structures on ℂ 3 superscript ℂ 3 \mathbb{C}^{3} . Math. Z. 214 (1993), no. 3, 499–509.
- 8[Ka ML] S. Kaliman, L. Makar-Limanov. On the Russell-Koras contractible threefolds. J. Algebraic Geom. 6 (1997), no. 2, 247–268.
