Manifestations of minimum-bias dijets in high-energy nuclear collisions

TL;DR

This paper investigates how minimum-bias dijets contribute to high-energy nuclear collision data, challenging the dominant flow-QGP interpretation by comparing different analysis methods and emphasizing the significance of jet manifestations.

Contribution

It introduces an alternative two-component model and compares analysis methods, highlighting the importance of MB dijets over flow-based explanations in interpreting collision data.

Findings

MB dijets account for features attributed to flow phenomena

Type B methods retain more information from primary data

MB jet contributions challenge the flow-QGP narrative

Abstract

Dijets observed near midrapidity in high-energy nuclear collisions result from large-angle scattering of low-$x$ partons (gluons) within projectile hadrons as a signature manifestation of QCD. Within the same collisions it has been claimed that hydrodynamic flows (radial, elliptic and "higher harmonic" flows) carried by a dense QCD medium or quark-gluon plasma (QGP) dominate the observed hadronic final state. The flow-QGP narrative is imposed {\em a priori} on primary particle data, and of all possible analysis methods a subset A that seems to support that narrative is preferred. The present study explores an alternative minimum-bias (MB) jet narrative -- quantitative correspondence of MB dijet manifestations in the hadronic final state with measured {\em isolated jet} properties. The latter incorporates a different set of methods B that emerge from inductive study of primary particle data without {\em a priori} assumptions. The resulting system of methods and data manifestations is represented by a two-component (soft + hard) model (TCM) of hadron production. A survey of methods reveals that type A tends to discard substantial information carried by primary particle data whereas type B retains almost all information in both primary particle data from nuclear collisions and from isolated jets. The main goal of the present study is a review of MB dijet contributions to high-energy collisions in small and large systems relative to measured isolated-jet properties. Representative analysis methods from types A and B are compared in the context of MB jet manifestations. This study suggests that at least some data features commonly attributed to flows actually result from MB dijets and thereby challenges the flow-QGP narrative.