A Model of Multi-Agent Consensus for Vague and Uncertain Beliefs

TL;DR

This paper presents a model for multi-agent consensus that incorporates vagueness and uncertainty, enabling agents with conflicting beliefs to reach a shared, crisp, and certain belief through a novel combination operator and simulations.

Contribution

It introduces a new belief combination operator leveraging borderline truth values and demonstrates its effectiveness in consensus formation under various influence scenarios.

Findings

Consensus operators lead to convergence to a shared belief.

Combining consensus with evidence updating accelerates convergence.

Belief quality influences the convergence to high-quality shared beliefs.

Abstract

Consensus formation is investigated for multi-agent systems in which agents' beliefs are both vague and uncertain. Vagueness is represented by a third truth state meaning \emph{borderline}. This is combined with a probabilistic model of uncertainty. A belief combination operator is then proposed which exploits borderline truth values to enable agents with conflicting beliefs to reach a compromise. A number of simulation experiments are carried out in which agents apply this operator in pairwise interactions, under the bounded confidence restriction that the two agents' beliefs must be sufficiently consistent with each other before agreement can be reached. As well as studying the consensus operator in isolation we also investigate scenarios in which agents are influenced either directly or indirectly by the state of the world. For the former we conduct simulations which combine consensus formation with belief updating based on evidence. For the latter we investigate the effect of assuming that the closer an agent's beliefs are to the truth the more visible they are in the consensus building process. In all cases applying the consensus operators results in the population converging to a single shared belief which is both crisp and certain. Furthermore, simulations which combine consensus formation with evidential updating converge faster to a shared opinion which is closer to the actual state of the world than those in which beliefs are only changed as a result of directly receiving new evidence. Finally, if agent interactions are guided by belief quality measured as similarity to the true state of the world, then applying the consensus operator alone results in the population converging to a high quality shared belief.