Sub-millimeter Spatial Oscillations of Newton's Constant: Theoretical Models and Laboratory Tests

TL;DR

This paper explores theoretical models predicting sub-millimeter oscillations in Newton's gravitational constant and tests these predictions using torsion balance experiments, finding slight, statistically insignificant hints of such oscillations.

Contribution

It identifies nonlocal gravity theories as naturally stable models with sub-millimeter oscillations and analyzes experimental data for potential signatures of these deviations.

Findings

Oscillating deviations fit the data better than constant Newtonian residuals.

Best-fit wavelength matches the dark energy length scale (~0.1mm).

Statistical significance of the fit is below 2 sigma.

Abstract

We investigate the viability of sub-millimeter wavelength oscillating deviations from the Newtonian potential at both the theoretical and the experimental/observational level. At the theoretical level such deviations are generic predictions in a wide range of extensions of General Relativity (GR) including $f(R)$ theories, massive Brans-Dicke theories, compactified extra dimension models and nonlocal extensions of GR. However, the range of parameters associated with such oscillating deviations is usually connected with instabilities. An exception emerges in nonlocal gravity theories where oscillating deviations from Newtonian potential occur naturally on sub-millimeter scales without instabilities. As an example of a model with unstable Newtonian oscillations we review an $f(R)$ expansion around General Relativity of the form $f(R)=R+\frac{1}{6 m^2} R^2$ with $m^2<0$ pointing out possible stabilization mechanisms. As an example of a model with stable Newtonian oscillations we discuss nonlocal gravity theories. If such oscillations are realized in Nature on sub-millimeter scales, a signature is expected in torsion balance experiments testing Newton's law. We search for such a signature in the torsion balance data of the Washington experiment (combined torque residuals) testing Newton's law at sub-millimeter scales. We show that an oscillating residual ansatz with spatial wavelength $\lambda \simeq 0.1mm$ provides a better fit to the data compared to the residual Newtonian constant ansatz by $\Delta \chi^2 = -15$. Similar improved fits, also occur in about $10\%$ of Monte Carlo realizations of Newtonian data. Thus, the significance level of this improved fit is at a level of not more than $2\sigma$. The energy scale corresponding to this best fit wavelength is identical to the dark energy length scale $\lambda_{de} \equiv\sqrt[4]{\hbar c/\rho_{ de}}\approx 0.1mm$.