The role of viscosity contrast on plume structure in laboratory modeling of mantle convection

TL;DR

This study uses laboratory experiments to investigate how viscosity contrast influences plume structures in mantle convection, revealing morphological transitions from dendritic to spherical plumes and linking these to geophysical regimes like hot spots and subduction.

Contribution

It provides the first experimental evidence of how viscosity ratio U affects plume morphology and dynamics, bridging laboratory models with mantle convection regimes.

Findings

Plume morphology transitions from dendritic to spherical with increasing U.

High U plumes resemble mantle hot spots with mushroom-shaped heads.

Low U plumes develop into sheet-like structures similar to subduction zones.

Abstract

We have conducted laboratory experiments to model important aspects of plumes in mantle convection. We focus on the role of the viscosity ratio U (between the ambient fluid and the plume fluid) in determining the plume structure and dynamics. In our experiments, we are able to capture geophysical convection regimes relevant to mantle convection both for hot spots (when U > 1) and plate-subduction (when U < 1) regimes. The planar laser induced fluorescence (PLIF) technique is used for flow visualization and characterizing the plume structures. The convection is driven by compositional buoyancy generated by the perfusion of lighter fluid across a permeable mesh and the viscosity ratio U is systematically varied over a range from 1/300 to 2500. The planform, near the bottom boundary for U=1, exhibits a well-known dendritic line plume structure. As the value of U is increased, a progressive morphological transition is observed from the dendritic-plume structure to discrete spherical plumes, accompanied with thickening of the plumes and an increase in the plume spacing. In the vertical section, mushroom-shaped plume heads at U=1 change into intermittent spherical-blob shaped plumes at high U, resembling mantle plume hot spots in mantle convection. In contrast, for low values of U (~1/300), the regime corresponds to subduction of plates in the mantle. In this regime, we observe for the first time that plumes arise from a thick boundary with cellular structure and develop into sheet-plumes. We use experimental data to quantify these morphological changes and mixing dynamics of the plumes at different regimes of U. We also compare our observations on plume spacing with various models reported in the literature by varying the viscosity ratio and the buoyancy flux.