Distinguishing the nonjet azimuth quadrupole from QCD jets and hydrodynamic flows via 2D angular correlations and quadrupole spectrum analysis

TL;DR

This paper isolates and analyzes the nonjet quadrupole component in high-energy nuclear collisions, revealing it differs from flow or hydro interpretations and suggesting a unique QCD mechanism.

Contribution

It demonstrates that the nonjet quadrupole spectra are distinct from single-particle spectra and are consistent with a universal boosted hadron source, challenging traditional flow models.

Findings

Nonjet quadrupole spectra differ from single-particle spectra.

Quadrupole spectra indicate a common boosted hadron source.

Shape of quadrupole spectra remains consistent from RHIC to LHC energies.

Abstract

According to the flow narrative commonly applied to high-energy nuclear collisions a 1D cylindrical-quadrupole component of 2D angular correlations conventionally denoted by quantity $v_2$ is interpreted to represent elliptic flow: azimuth modulation of transverse or radial flow in noncentral nucleus-nucleus (A-A) collisions. The nonjet (NJ) quadrupole component exhibits various properties inconsistent with a flow or hydro interpretation, including the observation that NJ-quadrupole centrality variation in $A$-$A$ collisions has no relation to strongly-varying jet modification ("jet quenching") in those collisions commonly attributed to jet interaction with a dense flowing medium. In the present study I report isolation of quadrupole spectra from $p_t$-differential $v_2(p_t)$ data obtained at the relativistic heavy ion collider (RHIC) and large hadron collider (LHCr). I demonstrate that NJ quadrupole spectra have characteristics very different from the single-particle spectra for most hadrons, that quadrupole spectra indicate a common boosted hadron source for a small minority of hadrons that "carry" the quadrupole structure, that the narrow source-boost distribution is characteristic of an expanding thin cylindrical shell (also strongly contradicting a hydro interpretation), and that in the boost frame a single universal quadrupole spectrum (L\'evy distribution) on transverse mass $m_t$ accurately describes data for several hadron species scaled according to their statistical-model abundances. The quadrupole spectrum shape changes very little from RHIC to LHC energies. Taken in combination those characteristics strongly suggest a unique {\em nonflow} (and nonjet) QCD mechanism for the NJ quadrupole conventionally represented by $v_2$.