A Normalizing Computation Rule for Propositional Extensionality in Higher-Order Minimal Logic

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new propositional higher-order minimal logic system that enables computation with propositional extensionality without requiring cubical type theory's nominal extension, ensuring canonicity and formalization in Agda.

Contribution

It proposes PHOML, a logic system with a novel normalizing computation rule for propositional extensionality, avoiding the need for cubical type theory extensions.

Findings

System satisfies canonicity: closed terms reduce to canonical forms

Formalized in Agda, ensuring correctness and reproducibility

Allows definitional equalities not present in cubical type theory

Abstract

The univalence axiom expresses the principle of extensionality for dependent type theory. However, if we simply add the univalence axiom to type theory, then we lose the property of canonicity - that every closed term computes to a canonical form. A computation becomes `stuck' when it reaches the point that it needs to evaluate a proof term that is an application of the univalence axiom. So we wish to find a way to compute with the univalence axiom. While this problem has been solved with the formulation of cubical type theory, where the computations are expressed using a nominal extension of lambda-calculus, it may be interesting to explore alternative solutions, which do not require such an extension. As a first step, we present here a system of propositional higher-order minimal logic (PHOML). There are three kinds of typing judgement in PHOML. There are terms which inhabit types, which are the simple types over $\Omega$. There are proofs which inhabit propositions, which are the terms of type $\Omega$. The canonical propositions are those constructed from $\bot$ by implication $\supset$. Thirdly, there are paths which inhabit equations $M =_A N$, where $M$ and $N$ are terms of type $A$. There are two ways to prove an equality: reflexivity, and propositional extensionality - logically equivalent propositions are equal. This system allows for some definitional equalities that are not present in cubical type theory, namely that transport along the trivial path is identity. We present a call-by-name reduction relation for this system, and prove that the system satisfies canonicity: every closed typable term head-reduces to a canonical form. This work has been formalised in Agda.