Estimating scaled treatment effects with multiple outcomes

TL;DR

This paper introduces nonparametric methods for estimating and testing scaled treatment effects across multiple outcomes, accommodating covariate effects and applicable to both randomized and observational studies.

Contribution

It proposes novel scaled effect measures and efficient estimation techniques for multiple outcomes, extending analysis capabilities beyond single-outcome studies.

Findings

Methods are doubly robust and nonparametric.

Simulation and data analysis demonstrate effectiveness.

Applicable to high-dimensional covariate settings.

Abstract

In classical study designs, the aim is often to learn about the effects of a treatment or intervention on a single outcome; in many modern studies, however, data on multiple outcomes are collected and it is of interest to explore effects on multiple outcomes simultaneously. Such designs can be particularly useful in patient-centered research, where different outcomes might be more or less important to different patients. In this paper we propose scaled effect measures (via potential outcome notation) that translate effects on multiple outcomes to a common scale, using mean-variance and median-interquartile-range -based standardizations. We present efficient, nonparametric, doubly robust methods for estimating these scaled effects (and weighted average summary measures), and for testing the null hypothesis that treatment affects all outcomes equally. We also discuss methods for exploring how treatment effects depend on covariates (i.e., effect modification). In addition to describing efficiency theory for our estimands and the asymptotic behavior of our estimators, we illustrate the methods in a simulation study and a data analysis. Importantly, and in contrast to much of the literature concerning effects on multiple outcomes, our methods are nonparametric and can be used not only in randomized trials to yield increased efficiency, but also in observational studies with high-dimensional covariates to reduce confounding bias.