Testing the two planes of satellites in the Centaurus Group

TL;DR

This study investigates the distribution of satellite galaxies in the Centaurus Group, testing the existence of two parallel planes and finding evidence that suggests a single dominant plane aligned with Cen A, challenging previous bimodal claims.

Contribution

The paper combines new dwarf galaxy data with existing samples to statistically assess the satellite galaxy distribution, providing evidence for a single plane rather than two parallel planes.

Findings

Support for a bimodal galaxy distribution with previous data

Inclusion of new data reduces bimodality significance

Evidence for a single dominant satellite plane around Cen A

Abstract

The existence of satellite galaxy planes poses a major challenge for the standard picture of structure formation with non-baryonic dark matter. Recently Tully et al. (2015) reported the discovery of two almost parallel planes in the nearby Cen A group using mostly high-mass galaxies (M$_B$ $<$ -10 mag) in their analysis. Our team detected a large number of new group member candidates in the Cen A group (M\"uller et al. 2016). This dwarf galaxy sample combined with other recent results from the literature enables us to test the galaxy distribution in the direction of the Cen A group and to determine the statistical significance of the geometric alignment. Taking advantage of the fact that the two galaxy planes lie almost edge-on along the line of sight, the newly found 13 group members by Crnojevic et al. (2014, 2016) and our 16 new Cen A group candidates (M\"uller et al. 2016) can be assigned relative to the two planes. We use various statistical methods to test whether the distribution of galaxies follows a single normal distribution or shows evidence of bimodality as it has been reported earlier. We confirm that the data used for the Tully et al. (2015) study support the picture of a bimodal structure. However, when the new galaxy samples are included, the gap between the two galaxy planes is closing and the significance level of the bimodality is reduced. Instead, the plane that contains Cen A becomes more prominent. We found evidence that the galaxy system around Cen A is made up of only one plane of satellites. This plane is almost orthogonal to the dust plane of Cen A. Accurate distances to the new dwarf galaxies will be required to measure the precise 3D distribution of the galaxies around Cen A.