Magnetic field morphology in nearby molecular clouds as revealed by starlight and submillimetre polarization

TL;DR

This study compares magnetic field structures in nearby molecular clouds as revealed by starlight and submillimetre polarization, finding consistent orientations and turbulence characteristics at scales larger than 10 arcminutes.

Contribution

It provides a detailed comparison of magnetic field morphology inferred from starlight and submillimetre polarization, demonstrating their consistency and the impact of resolution differences.

Findings

Average field orientation dispersion is less than 20 degrees.

Field orientations from both methods agree within 5 degrees at 10' scales.

Differences at larger scales are consistent with resolution effects.

Abstract

Within four nearby (d < 160 pc) molecular clouds, we statistically evaluate the structure of the interstellar magnetic field, projected on the plane of the sky and integrated along the line of sight, as inferred from the polarized thermal emission of Galactic dust observed by Planck at 353 GHz and from the optical and NIR polarization of background starlight. We compare the dispersion of the field orientation directly in vicinities with an area equivalent to that subtended by the Planck effective beam at 353 GHz (10') and using the second-order structure functions of the field orientation angles. We find that the average dispersion of the starlight-inferred field orientations within 10'-diameter vicinities is less than 20 deg, and that at these scales the mean field orientation is on average within 5 deg of that inferred from the submillimetre polarization observations in the considered regions. We also find that the dispersion of starlight polarization orientations and the polarization fractions within these vicinities are well reproduced by a Gaussian model of the turbulent structure of the magnetic field, in agreement with the findings reported by the Planck collaboration at scales greater than 10' and for comparable column densities. At scales greater than 10', we find differences of up to 14.7 deg between the second-order structure functions obtained from starlight and submillimetre polarization observations in the same positions in the plane of the sky, but comparison with a Gaussian model of the turbulent structure of the magnetic field indicates that these differences are small and are consistent with the difference in angular resolution between both techniques.