A counterexample to Thiagarajan's conjecture on regular event structures

TL;DR

This paper disproves Thiagarajan's conjecture by providing a counterexample of a regular event structure that cannot be labeled regularly, using geometric and combinatorial constructions related to CAT(0) cube complexes.

Contribution

It introduces a specific counterexample to Thiagarajan's conjecture, connecting geometric group theory with concurrency models, and proves the conjecture holds under certain hyperbolic conditions.

Findings

Counterexample derived from Wise's nonpositively curved square complex.

Disproves the conjecture that regular event structures always admit a regular nice labeling.

Proves the conjecture holds for hyperbolic CAT(0) cube complex domains.

Abstract

We provide a counterexample to a conjecture by Thiagarajan (1996 and 2002) that regular event structures correspond exactly to event structures obtained as unfoldings of finite 1-safe Petri nets. The same counterexample is used to disprove a closely related conjecture by Badouel, Darondeau, and Raoult (1999) that domains of regular event structures with bounded $\natural$-cliques are recognizable by finite trace automata. Event structures, trace automata, and Petri nets are fundamental models in concurrency theory. There exist nice interpretations of these structures as combinatorial and geometric objects. Namely, from a graph theoretical point of view, the domains of prime event structures correspond exactly to median graphs; from a geometric point of view, these domains are in bijection with CAT(0) cube complexes. A necessary condition for both conjectures to be true is that domains of regular event structures (with bounded $\natural$-cliques) admit a regular nice labeling. To disprove these conjectures, we describe a regular event domain (with bounded $\natural$-cliques) that does not admit a regular nice labeling. Our counterexample is derived from an example by Wise (1996 and 2007) of a nonpositively curved square complex whose universal cover is a CAT(0) square complex containing a particular plane with an aperiodic tiling. We prove that other counterexamples to Thiagarajan's conjecture arise from aperiodic 4-way deterministic tile sets of Kari and Papasoglu (1999) and Lukkarila (2009). On the positive side, using breakthrough results by Agol (2013) and Haglund and Wise (2008, 2012) from geometric group theory, we prove that Thiagarajan's conjecture is true for regular event structures whose domains occur as principal filters of hyperbolic CAT(0) cube complexes which are universal covers of finite nonpositively curved cube complexes.