The impact of JWST broad-band filter choice on photometric redshift estimation

TL;DR

This study evaluates how different JWST broad-band filter combinations affect the accuracy of photometric redshift estimates for galaxies, emphasizing the importance of certain wavelength data and signal-to-noise ratios.

Contribution

It provides a comprehensive analysis of filter choices and their impact on photometric redshift accuracy, including the benefits of adding MIRI data to NIRCam observations.

Findings

Adding MIRI photometry improves redshift estimates, especially at high z.

Ancillary data at wavelengths <0.6 μm are crucial to reduce low-z interloper contamination.

High signal-to-noise ratios (≥10) are essential for accurate zphot at z=7-10.

Abstract

The determination of galaxy redshifts in James Webb Space Telescope (JWST)'s blank-field surveys will mostly rely on photometric estimates, based on the data provided by JWST's Near-Infrared Camera (NIRCam) at 0.6-5.0 {\mu}m and Mid Infrared Instrument (MIRI) at {\lambda}>5.0 {\mu}m. In this work we analyse the impact of choosing different combinations of NIRCam and MIRI broad-band filters (F070W to F770W), as well as having ancillary data at {\lambda}<0.6 {\mu}m, on the derived photometric redshifts (zphot) of a total of 5921 real and simulated galaxies, with known input redshifts z=0-10. We found that observations at {\lambda}<0.6 {\mu}m are necessary to control the contamination of high-z samples by low-z interlopers. Adding MIRI (F560W and F770W) photometry to the NIRCam data mitigates the absence of ancillary observations at {\lambda}<0.6 {\mu}m and improves the redshift estimation. At z=7-10, accurate zphot can be obtained with the NIRCam broad bands alone when S/N>=10, but the zphot quality significantly degrades at S/N<=5. Adding MIRI photometry with one magnitude brighter depth than the NIRCam depth allows for a redshift recovery of 83-99%, depending on SED type, and its effect is particularly noteworthy for galaxies with nebular emission. The vast majority of NIRCam galaxies with [F150W]=29 AB mag at z=7-10 will be detected with MIRI at [F560W, F770W]<28 mag if these sources are at least mildly evolved or have spectra with emission lines boosting the mid-infrared fluxes.