On the mass of atoms in molecules: Beyond the Born-Oppenheimer approximation

TL;DR

This paper develops a rigorous theoretical framework to incorporate electronic inertia into nuclear mass calculations in molecules, improving the accuracy of vibrational spectra predictions beyond the traditional Born-Oppenheimer approximation.

Contribution

It introduces a perturbative method based on exact electron-nuclear wave function factorization to include electronic effects in nuclear mass calculations.

Findings

Enhanced accuracy in vibrational spectra predictions.

Framework applicable to general electron-nuclear systems.

Significant improvements demonstrated in proton transfer models.

Abstract

Describing the dynamics of nuclei in molecules requires a potential energy surface, which is traditionally provided by the Born-Oppenheimer or adiabatic approximation. However, we also need to assign masses to the nuclei. There, the Born-Oppenheimer picture does not account for the inertia of the electrons and only bare nuclear masses are considered. Nowadays, experimental accuracy challenges the theoretical predictions of rotational and vibrational spectra and requires to include the participation of electrons in the internal motion of the molecule. More than 80 years after the original work of Born and Oppenheimer, this issue still is not solved in general. Here, we present a theoretical and numerical framework to address this problem in a general and rigorous way. Starting from the exact factorization of the electron-nuclear wave function, we include electronic effects beyond the Born-Oppenheimer regime in a perturbative way via position-dependent corrections to the bare nuclear masses. This maintains an adiabatic-like point of view: the nuclear degrees of freedom feel the presence of the electrons via a single potential energy surface, whereas the inertia of electrons is accounted for and the total mass of the system is recovered. This constitutes a general framework for describing the mass acquired by slow degrees of freedom due to the inertia of light, bounded particles. We illustrate it with a model of proton transfer, where the light particle is the proton, and with corrections to the vibrational spectra of molecules. Inclusion of the light particle inertia allows to gain orders of magnitude in accuracy.