Waiting for Unruh

TL;DR

This paper investigates how long an accelerated detector must interact with a quantum field to observe Unruh temperature thermality, revealing that interaction duration and switching protocols critically influence the emergence of thermality at large energy gaps.

Contribution

It provides a detailed analysis of the conditions under which thermality appears for a pointlike Unruh-DeWitt detector, highlighting the importance of interaction duration and switching functions in the large energy gap limit.

Findings

Thermality cannot hold at fixed interaction duration as energy gap increases.

Detailed balance can be achieved if interaction duration grows as a power-law in energy gap with proper switching.

Faster-than-polynomial growth of interaction duration is required for thermality with fixed switch-on/off intervals.

Abstract

How long does a uniformly accelerated observer need to interact with a quantum field in order to record thermality in the Unruh temperature? We address this question for a pointlike Unruh-DeWitt detector, coupled linearly to a real Klein-Gordon field of mass $m\ge0$ and treated within first order perturbation theory, in the limit of large detector energy gap $E_{\text{gap}}$. We first show that when the interaction duration $\Delta T$ is fixed, thermality in the sense of detailed balance cannot hold as $E_{\text{gap}}\to\infty$, and this property generalises from the Unruh effect to any Kubo-Martin-Schwinger state satisfying certain technical conditions. We then specialise to a massless field in four spacetime dimensions and show that detailed balance does hold when $\Delta T$ grows as a power-law in $E_{\text{gap}}$ as $E_{\text{gap}}\to\infty$, provided the switch-on and switch-off intervals are stretched proportionally to $\Delta T$ and the switching function has sufficiently strong Fourier decay. By contrast, if $\Delta T$ grows by stretching a plateau in which the interaction remains at constant strength but keeping the duration of the switch-on and switch-off intervals fixed, detailed balance at $E_{\text{gap}}\to\infty$ requires $\Delta T$ to grow faster than any polynomial in $E_{\text{gap}}$, under mild technical conditions. These results also hold for a static detector in a Minkowski heat bath. The results limit the utility of the large $E_{\text{gap}}$ regime as a probe of thermality in time-dependent versions of the Hawking and Unruh effects, such as an observer falling into a radiating black hole. They may also have implications on the design of prospective experimental tests of the Unruh effect.