Surface density effects in quenching: cause or effect?

TL;DR

This paper demonstrates through a simple toy model that the observed correlations between galaxy structure and star-formation rates can arise naturally from size-mass evolution, challenging the idea that structure directly influences quenching.

Contribution

The study introduces a toy model showing that galaxy structural correlations with star-formation are likely due to size-mass evolution, not direct causation, and reproduces several observed galaxy properties.

Findings

Reproduces the sharp surface density threshold for quenching.

Matches the evolution of the quenching threshold with redshift.

Explains the apparent curvature in the Main Sequence sSFR-mass relation.

Abstract

There are very strong observed correlations between the specific star-formation rates (sSFR) of galaxies and their mean surface mass densities, {\Sigma}, as well as other aspects of their internal structure. These strong correlations have often been taken to indicate that the internal structure of a galaxy must play a major physical role, directly or indirectly, in the control of star-formation. In this paper we show by means of a very simple toy model that these correlations can arise naturally without any such physical role once the observed evolution of the size-mass relation for star-forming galaxies is taken into account. In particular, the model reproduces the sharp threshold in {\Sigma} between galaxies that are star-forming and those that are quenched, and the evolution of this threshold with redshift. Similarly, it produces iso-quenched-fraction contours in the ${f_Q(m,R_e)}$ plane that are almost exactly parallel to lines of constant {\Sigma} for centrals and shallower for satellites. It does so without any dependence on quenching on size or {\Sigma}, and without invoking any differences between centrals and satellites, beyond the different mass-dependences of their quenching laws. The toy-model also reproduces several other observations, including the sSFR gradients within galaxies and the appearance of inside-out build-up of passive galaxies. Finally, it is shown that curvature in the Main Sequence sSFR-mass relation can produce curvature in the apparent B/T ratios with mass. Our analysis therefore suggests that many of the strong correlations that are observed between galaxy structure and sSFR may well be a consequence of things unrelated to quenching and should not be taken as evidence of the physical processes that drive quenching.