Calibration of evolutionary diagnostics in high-mass star formation

TL;DR

This study calibrates the L/M ratio as an evolutionary indicator for high-mass star-forming clumps, using molecular thermometry to identify three distinct star formation phases based on temperature and luminosity/mass ratios.

Contribution

It provides a quantitative calibration linking L/M ratios to specific evolutionary stages in massive star formation, supported by molecular temperature measurements.

Findings

Three L/M ranges correspond to different star formation phases.

Clumps with L/M<1 are cold (<30K) and inactive.

Clumps with L/M>10 show increasing temperatures and signs of ZAMS stars.

Abstract

The evolutionary classification of massive clumps that are candidate progenitors of high-mass young stars and clusters relies on a variety of independent diagnostics based on observables from the near-infrared to the radio. A promising evolutionary indicator for massive and dense cluster-progenitor clumps is the L/M ratio between the bolometric luminosity and the mass of the clumps. With the aim of providing a quantitative calibration for this indicator we used SEPIA/APEX to obtain CH3C2H(12-11) observations, that is an excellent thermometer molecule probing densities > 10^5 cm^-3 , toward 51 dense clumps with M>1000 solar masses, and uniformly spanning -2 < Log(L/M) < 2.3. We identify three distinct ranges of L/M that can be associated to three distinct phases of star formation in massive clumps. For L/M <1 no clump is detected in CH3C2H , suggesting an inner envelope temperature below 30K. For 1< L/M < 10 we detect 58% of the clumps, with a temperature between 30 and 35 K independently from the exact value of L/M; such clumps are building up luminosity due to the formation of stars, but no star is yet able to significantly heat the inner clump regions. For L/M> 10 we detect all the clumps, with a gas temperature rising with Log(L/M), marking the appearance of a qualitatively different heating source within the clumps; such values are found towards clumps with UCHII counterparts, suggesting that the quantitative difference in T - L/M behaviour above L/M >10 is due to the first appearance of ZAMS stars in the clumps.