High temporal variability in the occurrence of consumer-resource interactions in ecological networks

TL;DR

This study reveals that consumer-resource interactions in marine ecological networks are highly variable over time, with most interactions being transient, challenging the traditional view of static ecological communities.

Contribution

It provides empirical evidence of low temporal persistence in ecological interactions and highlights the importance of considering temporal variability in ecological network analysis.

Findings

Most interactions had low temporal persistence.

A common exponential decay pattern described interaction rank-frequency.

Low-frequency interactions contributed to site similarity.

Abstract

Ecological networks are theoretical abstractions that represent ecological communities. These networks are usually defined as static entities, in which the occurrence of a particular interaction between species is considered fixed despite the intrinsic dynamics of ecological systems. However, empirical analysis of the temporal variation of trophic interactions is constrained by the lack of data with high spatial, temporal, and taxonomic resolution. Here, we evaluate the spatiotemporal variability of multiple consumer-resource interactions of large marine networks. The tropic interactions of all of the analyzed networks had low temporal persistence, which was well described by a common exponential decay in the rank-frequency relationship of consumer-resource interactions. This common pattern of low temporal persistence was evident despite the dissimilarities of environmental conditions among sites. Between-site rank correlations of frequency of occurrence of interactions ranged from 0.59 to 0.73. After removing the interactions with <50% frequency, the between-site correlations decreased to values between 0.60 and 0.28, indicating that low-frequency interactions accounted for the apparent similarities between sites. Our results showed that the communities studied were characterized by few persistent interactions and a large number of transient trophic interactions. We suggest that consumer-resource temporal asynchrony in addition to varying local environmental conditions and opportunistic foraging could be among the mechanisms generating the observed rank-frequency relationship of trophic interactions. Therefore, our results question the analysis of ecological communities as static and persistent natural entities and stress the need for strengthening the analysis of temporal variability in ecological networks and long-term studies.