A Cold Flare With Delayed Heating

TL;DR

This study analyzes a peculiar solar flare exhibiting a 'cold' impulsive phase with delayed heating, revealing complex energy release and particle transport mechanisms involving small and large magnetic loops.

Contribution

It provides detailed observational and modeling insights into the energy release, particle acceleration, and delayed thermal response in a cold flare with loop interactions.

Findings

Weak thermal response from small loop electrons due to limited volume

Delayed plasma heating caused by slow energy losses in the big loop

Electron acceleration involved beamed distribution along the small loop's magnetic field

Abstract

Recently, a number of peculiar flares have been reported, which demonstrate significant non-thermal particle signatures with a low, if any, thermal emission, that implies close association of the observed emission with the primary energy release/electron acceleration region. This paper presents a flare that appears a "cold" one at the impulsive phase, while displaying a delayed heating later on. Using HXR data from \kw, microwave observations by SSRT, RSTN, NoRH and NoRP, context observations, and 3D modeling, we study the energy release, particle acceleration and transport, and the relationships between the nonthermal and thermal signatures. The flaring process is found to involve interaction between a small and a big loop and the accelerated particles divided in roughly equal numbers between them. Precipitation of the electrons from the small loop produced only weak thermal response because the loop volume was small, while the electrons trapped in the big loop lost most of their energy in the coronal part of the loop, which resulted in the coronal plasma heating but no or only weak chromospheric evaporation, and thus unusually weak soft X-ray emission. Energy losses of fast electrons in the big tenuous loop were slow resulting in the observed delay of the plasma heating. We determined that the impulsively accelerated electron population had a beamed angular distribution in the direction of electric force along the magnetic field of the small loop. The accelerated particle transport in big loop was primarily mediated by turbulent waves like in the other reported cold flares.