Energy-momentum tensors in linearized Einstein's theory and massive gravity: The question of uniqueness

TL;DR

This paper investigates the uniqueness of energy-momentum tensors in linearized Einstein's theory and massive gravity, identifying a unique symmetric tensor in each case and analyzing their properties without variational methods.

Contribution

It provides a non-variational derivation of unique symmetric energy-momentum tensors in linearized gravity and massive gravity, clarifying their relation and gauge dependence.

Findings

The linearized Landau-Lifshitz tensor is uniquely identified in linearized gravity.

A simpler symmetric tensor in massive gravity is constructed, differing by a superpotential.

Both tensors yield the same total quantities despite different forms.

Abstract

The question of the uniqueness of energy-momentum tensors in the linearized general relativity and in the linear massive gravity is analyzed without using variational techniques. We start from a natural ansatz for the form of the tensor (for example, that it is a linear combination of the terms quadratic in the first derivatives), and require it to be conserved as a consequence of field equations. In the case of the linear gravity in a general gauge we find a four-parametric system of conserved second-rank tensors which contains a unique symmetric tensor. This turns out to be the linearized Landau-Lifshitz pseudotensor employed often in full general relativity. We elucidate the relation of the four-parametric system to the expression proposed recently by Butcher et al. "on physical grounds" in harmonic gauge, and we show that the results coincide in the case of high-frequency waves in vacuum after a suitable averaging. In the massive gravity we show how one can arrive at the expression which coincides with the "generalized linear symmetric Landau-Lifshitz" tensor. However, there exists another uniquely given simpler symmetric tensor which can be obtained by adding the divergence of a suitable superpotential to the canonical energy-momentum tensor following from the Fierz-Pauli action. In contrast to the symmetric tensor derived by the Belinfante procedure which involves the second derivatives of the field variables, this expression contains only the field and its first derivatives. It is simpler than the generalized Landau-Lifshitz tensor but both yield the same total quantities since they differ by the divergence of a superpotential. We also discuss the role of the gauge conditions in the proofs of the uniqueness. In the Appendix, the use of the symbolic tensor manipulation software Cadabra is briefly described.