Universal Unitarity Triangle 2016 and the Tension Between $\Delta M_{s,d}$ and $\varepsilon_K$ in CMFV Models

TL;DR

This paper analyzes the tension between meson mixing observables and CP violation in CMFV models using recent lattice data, revealing potential signs of new physics beyond the model's flavor universality assumptions.

Contribution

It determines the Universal Unitarity Triangle within CMFV using new lattice results and identifies a significant tension indicating possible new physics contributions.

Findings

Significant tension between $\Delta M_{s,d}$ and $\varepsilon_K$ within CMFV.

Upper bounds on CKM elements derived from $\Delta M_s$ data.

Indication of new physics breaking flavor universality of $S(v)$.

Abstract

Motivated by the recently improved results from the Fermilab Lattice and MILC Collaborations on the hadronic matrix elements entering $\Delta M_{s,d}$ in $B_{s,d}^0-\bar B_{s,d}^0$ mixing, we determine the Universal Unitarity Triangle (UUT) in models with Constrained Minimal Flavour Violation (CMFV). Of particular importance are the very precise determinations of the ratio $|V_{ub}|/|V_{cb}|=0.0864\pm0.0025$ and of the angle $\gamma=(63.0\pm 2.1)^\circ$. They follow in this framework from the experimental values of $\Delta M_{d}/\Delta M_s$ and of the CP-asymmetry $S_{\psi K_S}$. As in CMFV models the new contributions to meson mixings can be described by a single flavour-universal variable $S(v)$, we next determine the CKM matrix elements $|V_{ts}|$, $|V_{td}|$, $|V_{cb}|$ and $|V_{ub}|$ as functions of $S(v)$ using the experimental value of $\Delta M_s$ as input. The lower bound on $S(v)$ in these models, derived by us in 2006, implies then upper bounds on these four CKM elements and on the CP-violating parameter $\varepsilon_K$, which turns out to be significantly below its experimental value. This strategy avoids the use of tree-level determinations of $|V_{ub}|$ and $|V_{cb}|$ that are presently subject to considerable uncertainties. On the other hand if $\varepsilon_K$ is used instead of $\Delta M_s$ as input, $\Delta M_{s,d}$ are found significantly above the data. In this manner we point out that the new lattice data have significantly sharpened the tension between $\Delta M_{s,d}$ and $\varepsilon_K$ within the CMFV framework. This implies the presence of new physics contributions beyond this framework that are responsible for the breakdown of the flavour universality of the function $S(v)$. We also present the implications of these results for $K^+\to\pi^+\nu\bar\nu$, $K_L\to\pi^0\nu\bar\nu$ and $B_{s,d}\to\mu^+\mu^-$ within the Standard Model.