Analysis of Location Management Schemes for MANET using Synthetic Mobility Models

TL;DR

This paper evaluates how different mobility models affect the performance of location management schemes in mobile ad hoc networks, highlighting the importance of realistic mobility simulation for protocol assessment.

Contribution

It introduces a simulation framework to compare location management schemes under various mobility models, emphasizing the impact of mobility assumptions on protocol performance.

Findings

Performance varies significantly with different mobility models.

Hierarchical and HLR/VLR schemes show different efficiencies under various mobility scenarios.

Simulation results highlight the need for realistic mobility modeling in protocol evaluation.

Abstract

In the performance evaluation of a protocol for an ad hoc network, the protocol should be tested under realistic conditions including, but not limited to, a sensible transmission range, limited buffer space for the storage of messages, representative data traffic models, and realistic movements of the mobile users and several mobility models that represent mobile nodes whose movements are dependent on each other (i.e., group mobility models ).The goal of this paper is to simulate the movements of mobile nodes within a network and present a number of mobility models in order to demonstrate its effect on Location management scheme for mobile ad hoc network or personal communication services networks. Specifically, to illustrate how the performance results of an ad hoc network protocol drastically change as a result of changing the mobility model simulated. Location management is a fundamental problem in personal communication services network. The current standard of location management is HLR/VLR scheme. It has been observed that the performance of any location management scheme depends on space requirements, bandwidth requirements and time requirements. To avoid certain drawbacks in HLR/VLR scheme, many approaches including hierarchical approaches have been suggested. Working set idea is chosen to analyze its performance for location management in PCS networks. Due to inadequacy of standard network simulators to provide the output in the format desired, a new location management simulator can be built. Two variants of working set idea viz. Working set scheme for HLR/VLR approach and working set scheme for hierarchical approach can be used and then compare the performance of HLR/VLR scheme and working set scheme using the results obtained by the simulator with respect to already available mobile activity traces.