Testing the mapping between redshift and cosmic scale factor

TL;DR

This paper tests the fundamental redshift-scale factor relation in cosmology by allowing for a generalized mapping and analyzing current BAO and SN data, revealing degeneracies with dark energy and limitations in constraining it.

Contribution

It introduces a framework to test the redshift-scale factor relation by jointly constraining cosmological parameters and a generalized redshift mapping using observational data.

Findings

Generalized redshift mapping is degenerate with dark energy.

Current data cannot constrain dark energy without high-redshift Ly-alpha measurements.

Marginalization over f(z) alters the matter-dark energy degeneracy.

Abstract

The canonical redshift-scale factor relation, 1/a=1+z, is a key element in the standard LambdaCDM model of the big bang cosmology. Despite its fundamental role, this relation has not yet undergone any observational tests since Lemaitre and Hubble established the expansion of the Universe. It is strictly based on the assumption of the Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker metric describing a locally homogeneous and isotropic universe and that photons move on null geodesics of the metric. Thus any violation of this assumption, within general relativity or modified gravity, can yield a different mapping between the model redshift z=1/a-1 and the actually observed redshift z_obs, i.e. z_obs neq z. Here we perform a simple test of consistency for the standard redshift-scale factor relation by determining simultaneous observational constraints on the concordance LambdaCDM cosmological parameters and a generalized redshift mapping z=f(z_obs). Using current baryon acoustic oscillations (BAO) and Type Ia supernova (SN) data we demonstrate that the generalized redshift mapping is strongly degenerated with dark energy. Marginalization over a class of monotonic functions f(z_obs) changes substantially degeneracy between matter and dark energy density: the density parameters become anti correlated with nearly vertical axis of degeneracy. Furthermore, we show that current SN and BAO data, analysed in a framework with the generalized redshift mapping, do not constrain dark energy unless the BAO data include the measurements from the Ly-alpha forest of high-redshift quasars.