Threshold games and cooperation on multiplayer graphs

TL;DR

This paper explores how network structure influences cooperation in multiplayer threshold games, revealing that most structures tend to decrease cooperation and that local neighborhood size critically impacts behavior.

Contribution

It introduces a class of nonlinear multiplayer threshold games and demonstrates how network topology affects cooperation levels, providing new insights into structured population dynamics.

Findings

Most network structures decrease cooperation compared to mean-field models.

Local neighborhood size significantly influences cooperative behavior.

Players behave as if in smaller, fully mixed populations based on network structure.

Abstract

Objective: The study investigates the effect on cooperation in multiplayer games, when the population from which all individuals are drawn is structured - i.e. when a given individual is only competing with a small subset of the entire population. Method: To optimize the focus on multiplayer effects, a class of games were chosen for which the payoff depends nonlinearly on the number of cooperators - this ensures that the game cannot be represented as a sum of pair-wise interactions, and increases the likelihood of observing behaviour different from that seen in two-player games. The chosen class of games are named "threshold games", and are defined by a threshold, $M > 0$, which describes the minimal number of cooperators in a given match required for all the participants to receive a benefit. The model was studied primarily through numerical simulations of large populations of individuals, each with interaction neighbourhoods described by various classes of networks. Results: When comparing the level of cooperation in a structured population to the mean-field model, we find that most types of structure lead to a decrease in cooperation. This is both interesting and novel, simply due to the generality and breadth of relevance of the model - it is likely that any model with similar payoff structure exhibits related behaviour. More importantly, we find that the details of the behaviour depends to a large extent on the size of the immediate neighbourhoods of the individuals, as dictated by the network structure. In effect, the players behave as if they are part of a much smaller, fully mixed, population, which we suggest an expression for.