Inferring the perturbation time from biological time course data

TL;DR

This paper introduces a Bayesian Gaussian Process-based method to accurately infer the exact time point of divergence in biological time course data following a perturbation, enhancing causal analysis in biological processes.

Contribution

We develop a novel non-parametric Bayesian approach to precisely estimate the perturbation time in biological time series data, which was not previously achievable with existing methods.

Findings

Method accurately estimates perturbation time in simulated data.

Applied to Arabidopsis data to identify transcriptional changes post-inoculation.

Open-source R package DEtime available for researchers.

Abstract

Time course data are often used to study the changes to a biological process after perturbation. Statistical methods have been developed to determine whether such a perturbation induces changes over time, e.g. comparing a perturbed and unperturbed time course dataset to uncover differences. However, existing methods do not provide a principled statistical approach to identify the specific time when the two time course datasets first begin to diverge after a perturbation; we call this the perturbation time. Estimation of the perturbation time for different variables in a biological process allows us to identify the sequence of events following a perturbation and therefore provides valuable insights into likely causal relationships. In this paper, we propose a Bayesian method to infer the perturbation time given time course data from a wild-type and perturbed system. We use a non-parametric approach based on Gaussian Process regression. We derive a probabilistic model of noise-corrupted and replicated time course data coming from the same profile before the perturbation time and diverging after the perturbation time. The likelihood function can be worked out exactly for this model and the posterior distribution of the perturbation time is obtained by a simple histogram approach, without recourse to complex approximate inference algorithms. We validate the method on simulated data and apply it to study the transcriptional change occurring in Arabidopsis following inoculation with P. syringae pv. tomato DC3000 versus the disarmed strain DC3000hrpA. An R package, DEtime, implementing the method is available at https://github.com/ManchesterBioinference/DEtime along with the data and code required to reproduce all the results.