Pore-scale simulations of drainage in granular materials: finite size effects and the representative elementary volume

TL;DR

This paper introduces a pore-scale model for two-phase flow in granular materials, highlighting size effects and the importance of large sample volumes for accurate saturation measurements, validated through experiments and simulations.

Contribution

The paper develops a pore network model based on Regular Triangulation for drainage in polydisperse spheres, emphasizing size effects and establishing minimal sample size requirements.

Findings

More than 20,000 spheres needed for accurate saturation measurement.

Small samples exhibit biased water content evolution.

Large samples (>64,000 spheres) reduce bias and improve statistical reliability.

Abstract

A pore-scale model is introduced for two-phase flow in dense packings of polydisperse spheres. The model is developed as a component of a more general hydromechanical coupling framework based on the discrete element method, which will be elaborated in future papers. Here the emphasis is on the generation of a network of pores mapping the void space between spherical grains, and the definition of local criteria governing the primary drainage process. The pore space is decomposed by Regular Triangulation, from which a set of pores connected by throats are identified. A local entry capillary pressure is evaluated for each throat, based on the balance of capillary pressure and surface tension at equilibrium. The model reflects the possible entrapment of disconnected patches of the receding wetting phase. It is validated by a comparison with drainage experiments. A series of simulations are reported to illustrate size and boundary effects, key questions when studying small samples made of spherical particles be it in simulations or experiments. Repeated tests on samples of different sizes give evolution of water content which are not only scattered but also strongly biased for small sample sizes. More than 20,000 spheres are needed to reduce the bias on saturation below 0.02. Additional statistics are generated by subsampling a large sample of 64,000 spheres. They suggest that the minimal sampling volume for evaluating saturation is one hundred times greater that the sampling volume needed for measuring porosity with the same accuracy. This requirement in terms of sample size induces a need for efficient computer codes. The method described herein has a low algorithmic complexity in order to satisfy this requirement. It will be well suited to further developments toward coupled flow-deformation problems in which evolution of the microstructure require frequent updates of the pore network.