Buckling transitions and clock order of two-dimensional Coulomb crystals

TL;DR

This paper explores the buckling transition in two-dimensional Coulomb crystals, revealing a rich phase diagram with thermal and quantum phase transitions, and proposes experimental setups with trapped ions and dipolar gases to observe these phenomena.

Contribution

It maps the buckling transition to the six-state clock model, predicting thermal and quantum phase transitions and intermediate critical phases in Coulomb crystals.

Findings

Thermal fluctuations induce two phase transitions with an intermediate critical phase.

The critical phase exhibits power-law correlations and broadened Bragg peaks.

Quantum fluctuations cause a quantum phase transition that shrinks the critical phase.

Abstract

Crystals of repulsively interacting ions in planar traps form hexagonal lattices, which undergo a buckling instability towards a multi-layer structure as the transverse trap frequency is reduced. Numerical and experimental results indicate that the new structure is composed of three planes, whose separation increases continuously from zero. We study the effects of thermal and quantum fluctuations by mapping this structural instability to the six-state clock model. A prominent implication of this mapping is that at finite temperature, fluctuations split the buckling instability into two thermal transitions, accompanied by the appearance of an intermediate critical phase. This phase is characterized by quasi-long-range order in the spatial tripartite pattern. It is manifested by broadened Bragg peaks at new wave vectors, whose line-shape provides a direct measurement of the temperature dependent exponent $\eta(T)$ characteristic of the power-law correlations in the critical phase. A quantum phase transition is found at the largest value of the critical transverse frequency: here the critical intermediate phase shrinks to zero. Moreover, within the ordered phase, we predict a crossover from classical to quantum behavior, signifying the emergence of an additional characteristic scale for clock order. We discuss experimental realizations with trapped ions and polarized dipolar gases, and propose that within accessible technology, such experiments can provide a direct probe of the rich phase diagram of the quantum clock model, not easily observable in condensed matter analogues. Therefore, this works highlights the potential for ionic and dipolar systems to serve as simulators for complex models in statistical mechanics and condensed matter physics.