Tiling strategies for optical follow-up of gravitational wave triggers by wide field of view telescopes

TL;DR

This paper develops and evaluates optimized tiling strategies for wide field optical telescopes to efficiently locate electromagnetic counterparts of gravitational wave sources, improving coverage and detection prospects.

Contribution

It introduces an optimal tiling strategy for gravitational wave sky-localizations and compares array versus single telescope configurations for follow-up observations.

Findings

Proposed tiling strategy improves sky coverage over naive methods.

Array of smaller telescopes enhances coverage efficiency by up to 50%.

Deeper observations with small aperture telescopes increase detection of faint counterparts.

Abstract

Binary neutron stars are among the most promising candidates for joint gravitational-wave and electromagnetic astronomy. The goal of this work is to investigate the strategy of using gravitational wave sky-localizations for binary neutron star systems, to search for electromagnetic counterparts using wide field of view optical telescopes. We examine various strategies of scanning the gravitational wave sky-localizations on the mock 2015-16 gravitational-wave events. We propose an optimal tiling-strategy that would ensure the most economical coverage of the gravitational wave sky-localization, while keeping in mind the realistic constrains of transient optical astronomy. Our analysis reveals that the proposed tiling strategy improves the sky-localization coverage over naive contour-covering method. The improvement is more significant for observations conducted using larger field of view telescopes, or for observations conducted over smaller confidence interval of gravitational wave sky-localization probability distribution. Next, we investigate the performance of the tiling strategy for telescope arrays and compare their performance against monolithic giant field of view telescopes. We observed that distributing the field of view of the telescopes into arrays of multiple telescopes significantly improves the coverage efficiency by as much as 50% over a single large FOV telescope in 2016 localizations while scanning around 100 sq. degrees. Finally, we studied the ability of optical counterpart detection by various types of telescopes. In Our analysis for a range of wide field-of-view telescopes we found improvement in detection upon sacrificing coverage of localization in order to achieve greater observation depth for very large field-of-view - small aperture telescopes, especially if the intrinsic brightness of the optical counterparts are weak.