The energy-momentum tensor and D-term of Q-clouds

TL;DR

This paper investigates the D-term of Q-clouds, an unstable field configuration, revealing that they have negative D-terms and discussing implications for the sign of D-terms in physical systems.

Contribution

The study analyzes Q-clouds to explore the sign of the D-term, providing new insights into their properties and challenging the assumption that positive D-terms are possible in stable systems.

Findings

Q-clouds have negative D-terms.

Q-clouds resemble BPS Skyrmions in some aspects.

Negative D-terms are observed even in unstable solutions.

Abstract

The D-term is, like mass and spin, a fundamental property related to the energy-momentum tensor. Yet it is not known experimentally for any particle. In all theoretical studies so far the D-terms of various particles were found negative. Early works gave rise to the assumption the negative sign could be related to stability. The emerging question is whether it is possible to find a field-theoretical system with a positive D-term. To shed some light on this question we investigate Q-clouds, an extreme parametric limit in the Q-ball system. Q-clouds are classically unstable solutions which delocalize, spread out over all space forming an infinitely dilute gas of free quanta, and are even energetically unstable against tunneling to plane waves. In short, these extremely unstable field configurations provide an ideal candidate system for our purposes. By studying the energy-momentum tensor we show that at any stage of the Q-cloud limit one deals with perfectly well-defined and, when viewed in appropriately scaled coordinates, non-dissipating non-topological solitonic solutions. We investigate in detail their properties, and find new physical interpretations by observing that Q-clouds resemble BPS Skyrmions in certain aspects, and correspond to universal non-perturbative solutions in (complex) |\Phi|^4 theory. In particular, we show that also Q-cloud solutions have negative D-terms. Our findings do not prove that D-terms must always be negative. But they indicate that it is unlikely to realize a positive D-term in a consistent physical system.