Mid-IR spectra of Pre-Main Sequence Herbig stars: an explanation for the non-detections of water lines

TL;DR

This study investigates why water lines are rarely detected in the mid-IR spectra of disks around Herbig stars compared to T Tauri stars, suggesting observational limitations and intrinsic disk differences as causes.

Contribution

The paper uses detailed disk modeling to explain the low detection rate of water lines in Herbig star disks, highlighting the roles of observational sensitivity and disk structural differences.

Findings

Water line strength correlates with stellar luminosity.

Current observations are not sensitive enough to detect water lines in most models.

Higher spectral resolution is needed to detect water in disks.

Abstract

The mid-IR detection rate of water lines in disks around Herbig stars disks is about 5\%, while it is around 50\% for disks around TTauri stars. The reason for this is still unclear. In this study, we want to find an explanation for the different detection rates between low mass and high mass pre-main-sequence stars (PMSs) in the mid-IR regime. We run disk models with stellar parameters adjusted to spectral types B9 through M2, using the radiation thermo-chemical disk modeling code ProDiMo. We produce convolved spectra at the resolution of Spitzer IRS, JWST MIRI and VLT VISIR spectrographs. We apply random noise derived from typical Spitzer spectra for a direct comparison with observations. The strength of the mid-IR water lines correlates directly with the luminosity of the central star. We explored a small parameter space around a standard disk model, considering dust-to-gas mass ratio, disk gas mass, mixing coefficient for dust settling, flaring index, dust maximum size and size power law distribution index. The models show that it is possible to suppress the water emission, however, current observations are not sensitive enough to detect mid-IR lines in disks for most of the explored parameters. The presence of noise in the spectra, combined with the high continuum flux (noise level is proportional to the continuum flux), is the most likely explanation for the non detections towards Herbig stars. Mid-IR spectra with resolution higher than 20000 are needed to investigate water in protoplanetary disks. Intrinsic differences in disk structure, e.g. inner gaps, gas-to-dust ratio, dust size and distribution, and inner disk scale height, between Herbig and TTauri star disks are able to explain a lower water detection rate in disks around Herbig stars.