Nebular spectra of pair-instability supernovae

TL;DR

This study models nebular spectra of pair-instability supernovae to compare with observations, revealing spectral features and discrepancies with candidate events, thereby testing the PISN hypothesis.

Contribution

It provides detailed theoretical nebular spectra of PISNe at 1-3 years post-explosion, enabling direct comparison with observed supernovae and testing the PISN model predictions.

Findings

Most PISNe spectra are red with complete line blocking below 5000 Å.

High-mass PISNe produce featureless spectra due to faster expansion.

Discrepancies found between models and observed candidates SN 2007bi and PTF12dam.

Abstract

If very massive stars (M >~ 100 Msun) can form and avoid too strong mass loss during their evolution, they are predicted to explode as pair-instability supernovae (PISNe). One critical test for candidate events is whether their nucleosynthesis yields and internal ejecta structure, being revealed through nebular-phase spectra at t >~ 1 yr, match those of model predictions. Here we compute theoretical spectra based on model PISN ejecta at 1-3 years post-explosion to allow quantitative comparison with observations. The high column densities of PISNe lead to complete gamma-ray trapping for t >~ 2 years which, combined with fulfilled conditions of steady state, leads to bolometric supernova luminosities matching the 56Co decay. Most of the gamma-rays are absorbed by the deep-lying iron and silicon/sulphur layers. The ionization balance shows a predominantly neutral gas state, which leads to emission lines of Fe I, Si I, and S I. For low-mass PISNe the metal core expands slowly enough to produce a forest of distinct lines, whereas high-mass PISNe expand faster and produce more featureless spectra. Line blocking is complete below ~5000 A for several years, and the model spectra are red. The strongest line is typically [Ca II] 7291,7323, one of few lines from ionized species. We compare our models with proposed PISN candidates SN 2007bi and PTF12dam, finding discrepancies for several key observables and thus no support for a PISN interpretation. We discuss distinct spectral features predicted by the models, and the possibility of detecting pair-instability explosions among non-superluminous supernovae.