A Survey on Legacy and Emerging Technologies for Public Safety Communications

TL;DR

This paper surveys legacy and emerging public safety communication technologies, comparing LMRS and LTE, including simulations and experiments, to understand their capabilities and convergence for improved emergency response systems.

Contribution

It provides a comprehensive comparison of LMRS and LTE-based public safety networks, including simulation, experimental studies, and review of emerging technologies.

Findings

LTE offers broadband, ubiquitous, mission-critical support.

LMRS remains vital for critical voice communication.

Emerging technologies show potential for future public safety networks.

Abstract

Effective emergency and natural disaster management depend on the efficient mission-critical voice and data communication between first responders and victims. Land Mobile Radio System (LMRS) is a legacy narrowband technology used for critical voice communications with limited use for data applications. Recently Long Term Evolution (LTE) emerged as a broadband communication technology that has a potential to transform the capabilities of public safety technologies by providing broadband, ubiquitous, and mission-critical voice and data support. For example, in the United States, FirstNet is building a nationwide coast-to-coast public safety network based of LTE broadband technology. This paper presents a comparative survey of legacy and the LTE-based public safety networks, and discusses the LMRS-LTE convergence as well as mission-critical push-to-talk over LTE. A simulation study of LMRS and LTE band class 14 technologies is provided using the NS-3 open source tool. An experimental study of APCO-25 and LTE band class 14 is also conducted using software-defined radio, to enhance the understanding of the public safety systems. Finally, emerging technologies that may have strong potential for use in public safety networks are reviewed.