Consistent metallicity scale for cool dwarfs and giants. A benchmark test using the Hyades

TL;DR

This study develops a methodology to derive a consistent metallicity scale for both dwarf and giant stars in the Hyades cluster, using high-resolution spectroscopy and interferometry, addressing previous assumptions of uniform abundance scales.

Contribution

It introduces a novel calibration of microturbulence and compares methods to achieve consistent metallicity measurements across stellar types.

Findings

Consistent metallicity scale between dwarfs and giants is achievable.

Preferred method constrains stellar parameters independently of spectroscopy.

Classical spectroscopic method can produce reliable results with optimized line lists.

Abstract

In several instances chemical abundances of dwarf and giant stars are used simultaneously under the assumption that they share the same abundance scale. This assumption might have implications in different astrophysical contexts. We aim to ascertain a methodology capable of producing a consistent metallicity scale for giants and dwarfs. To achieve that, we analyzed giants and dwarfs in the Hyades open cluster. All these stars have archival high-resolution spectroscopic data obtained with HARPS and UVES. In addition, the giants have interferometric measurements of the angular diameters. We analyzed the sample with two methods. The first method constrains the atmospheric parameters independently from spectroscopy. For that we present a novel calibration of microturbulence based on 3D model atmospheres. The second method is the classical spectroscopic based on Fe lines. We also tested two line lists in an attempt to minimize possible non-LTE effects and to optimize the treatment of the giants. We show that it is possible to obtain a consistent metallicity scale between dwarfs and giants. The preferred method should constrain the three parameters $T_{\rm eff}$, $\log~g$, and $\xi$ independent of spectroscopy. In particular, the lines should be chosen to be free of blends in the spectra of giants. When attention is paid to the line list, the classical spectroscopic method can also produce consistent results. The metallicities derived with the well-constrained set of stellar parameters are consistent independent of the line list used. Therefore, for this cluster we favor the metallicity of +0.18$\pm$0.03 dex obtained with this method. The classical spectroscopic analysis, using the line list optimized for the giants, provides a metallicity of +0.14$\pm$0.03 dex, in agreement with previous works.