A Statistical Study of GRB X-ray Flares: Evidence of Ubiquitous Bulk Acceleration in the Emission Region

TL;DR

This study analyzes 85 bright X-ray flares from 63 GRBs, providing strong evidence that bulk acceleration in the emission region is common, supporting a Poynting-flux-dominated jet model for these phenomena.

Contribution

It offers a systematic analysis of the decay slopes of GRB X-ray flares, demonstrating that bulk acceleration is prevalent, which was not conclusively established before.

Findings

Over 66% of flares show decay slopes steeper than standard predictions.

Bulk acceleration is likely ubiquitous in X-ray flares.

Supports Poynting-flux-dominated jet composition.

Abstract

When emission in a conical relativistic jet ceases abruptly (or decays sharply), the observed decay light curve is controlled by the high-latitude "curvature effect". Recently, Uhm & Zhang found that the decay slopes of three GRB X-ray flares are steeper than what the standard model predicts. This requires bulk acceleration of the emission region, which is consistent with a Poynting-flux-dominated outflow. In this paper, we systematically analyze a sample of 85 bright X-ray flares detected in 63 Swift GRBs, and investigate the relationship between the temporal decay index $\alpha$ and spectral index $\beta$ during the steep decay phase of these flares. The $\alpha$ value depends on the choice of the zero time point $t_0$. We adopt two methods. "Method I" takes $t_0^I$ as the first rising data point of each flare, and is the most conservative approach. We find that at 99.9% condifence level 56/85 flares have decay slopes steeper than the simplest curvature effect prediction, and therefore, are in the acceleration regime. "Method II" extrapolates the rising light curve of each flare backwards until the flux density is three orders of magnitude lower than the peak flux density, and defines the corresponding time as the time zero point (t_0^II). We find that 74/85 flares fall into the acceleration regime at 99.9% condifence level. This suggests that bulk acceleration is common, may be even ubiquitous among X-ray flares, pointing towards a Poynting-flux-dominated jet composition for these events.