Collective phenomena in granular and atmospheric electrification

TL;DR

This study investigates how collective behaviors influence electrification in granular systems and atmospheric phenomena, revealing that large-scale effects dominate over material-specific properties in generating electric fields.

Contribution

The paper demonstrates through experiments that macroscopic electrification in granular systems is largely independent of particle material, emphasizing the role of collective phenomena.

Findings

All tested materials electrify similarly

Electric field amplitude depends on particle quantity

Large-scale collective effects dominate material properties

Abstract

In clouds of suspended particles (grains, droplets, spheres, crystals, etc.), collisions electrify the particles and the clouds, producing large electric potential differences over large scales. This is seen most spectacularly in the atmosphere as lighting in thunderstorms, thundersnow, dust storms, and volcanic ash plumes where multi-million-volt potential differences over scales of kilometers can be produced, but it is a general phenomenon in granular systems as a whole. The electrification process is not well understood, especially for electrification of insulating particles of the same material. To investigate the relative importances of particle properties (material, size, etc.) and collective phenomena (behaviors of systems at large scales not easily predicted from local dynamics) in granular and atmospheric electrification, we used a table-top experiment that mechanically shakes particles inside a cell where we measure the macroscopic electric field between the electrically conducting end plates. The measured electric fields are a result of capacitive coupling and direct charge transfer between the particles and the plates. Using a diverse range of mono-material particle sets (plastics, ceramic, glass, and metals), we found that all our particle materials electrify and show similar dynamics with long time-scale temporal variation and an electric field amplitude that depends on the particle quantity in a complex way. These results suggest that while particle properties do matter like previous investigations have shown, macroscopic electrification of solids is relatively material agnostic and large scale collective phenomena play a major role.