Design of the Millennium Villages Project Sampling Plan: a simulation study for a multi-module survey

TL;DR

This paper develops and evaluates a two-stage sampling plan for the Millennium Villages Project survey, aiming to optimize efficiency and precision across demographic groups through simulation-based analysis.

Contribution

It introduces a simulation-based approach to compare and recommend two-stage sampling designs tailored for multi-module surveys in rural development projects.

Findings

Two-stage sampling designs can improve survey efficiency.

Simulation results guide optimal sampling scheme selection.

Tradeoffs between design complexity and survey precision are identified.

Abstract

The Millennium Villages Project (MVP) is a ten-year integrated rural development project implemented in ten sub-Saharan African sites. At its conclusion we will conduct an evaluation of its causal effect on a variety of development outcomes, measured via household surveys in treatment and comparison areas. Outcomes are measured by six survey modules, with sample sizes for each demographic group determined by budget, logistics, and the group's vulnerability. We design a sampling plan that aims to reduce effort for survey enumerators and maximize precision for all outcomes. We propose two-stage sampling designs, sampling households at the first stage, followed by a second stage sample that differs across demographic groups. Two-stage designs are usually constructed by simple random sampling (SRS) of households and proportional within-household sampling, or probability proportional to size sampling (PPS) of households with fixed sampling within each. No measure of household size is proportional for all demographic groups, putting PPS schemes at a disadvantage. The SRS schemes have the disadvantage that multiple individuals sampled per household decreases efficiency due to intra-household correlation. We conduct a simulation study (using both design- and model-based survey inference) to understand these tradeoffs and recommend a sampling plan for the Millennium Villages Project. Similar design issues arise in other studies with surveys that target different demographic groups.