On the [CII]-SFR relation in high redshift galaxies

TL;DR

This study models [CII] emission in high-redshift galaxies using advanced simulations, revealing that [CII] emission mainly originates from PDRs and that observed deficits may result from feedback effects or low metallicity, challenging local relations.

Contribution

The paper enhances the Vallini et al. model by incorporating metallicity distribution, PDR contributions, and CMB effects to better predict [CII] emission in z~7 galaxies.

Findings

[CII] emission mainly from PDRs with minimal diffuse gas contribution.

Predicted high-z [CII]-SFR relation aligns with local dwarf galaxy observations.

Possible explanations for [CII] deficit include stellar feedback and low metallicity.

Abstract

After two ALMA observing cycles, only a handful of [CII] $158\,\mu m$ emission line searches in z>6 galaxies have reported a positive detection, questioning the applicability of the local [CII]-SFR relation to high-z systems. To investigate this issue we use the Vallini et al. 2013 (V13) model, based on high-resolution, radiative transfer cosmological simulations to predict the [CII] emission from the interstellar medium of a z~7 (halo mass $M_h=1.17\times10^{11}M_{\odot}$) galaxy. We improve the V13 model by including (a) a physically-motivated metallicity (Z) distribution of the gas, (b) the contribution of Photo-Dissociation Regions (PDRs), (c) the effects of Cosmic Microwave Background on the [CII] line luminosity. We study the relative contribution of diffuse neutral gas to the total [CII] emission ($F _{diff}/F_{tot}$) for different SFR and Z values. We find that the [CII] emission arises predominantly from PDRs: regardless of the galaxy properties, $F _{diff}/F_{tot}\leq 10$% since, at these early epochs, the CMB temperature approaches the spin temperature of the [CII] transition in the cold neutral medium ($T_{CMB}\sim T_s^{CNM}\sim 20$ K). Our model predicts a high-z [CII]-SFR relation consistent with observations of local dwarf galaxies ($0.02<Z/Z_{\odot}<0.5$). The [CII] deficit suggested by actual data ($L_{CII}<2.0\times 10^7 L_{\odot}$ in BDF3299 at z~7.1) if confirmed by deeper ALMA observations, can be ascribed to negative stellar feedback disrupting molecular clouds around star formation sites. The deviation from the local [CII]-SFR would then imply a modified Kennicutt-Schmidt relation in z>6 galaxies. Alternatively/in addition, the deficit might be explained by low gas metallicities ($Z<0.1 Z_{\odot}$).