Comment on 'Investigations into the impact of astronomical phenomena on the terrestrial biosphere and climate' (arXiv:1505.07856 [astro-ph.EP]) by Fabo Feng

TL;DR

This paper critiques Feng's work on astronomical phenomena's impact on Earth's biosphere and climate, highlighting fundamental issues and objections that undermine its conclusions.

Contribution

It provides a critical analysis pointing out key flaws and overlooked objections in Feng's study, emphasizing the importance of addressing prior critiques.

Findings

Feng's conclusions are challenged due to fundamental problems.

Previous objections by Melott and Bambach are not addressed in Feng's work.

The critique underscores the need for rigorous validation in this research area.

Abstract

This work by Feng and papers which published its conclusions do not cite nor do they deal with objections by the author published in 2013-2014. There are many fundamental problems. We will summarize here the principal problems, as published by Melott and Bambach which render irrelevant most of the work presented by Feng.