Deep near-IR observations of the Globular Cluster M4: Hunting for Brown Dwarfs

TL;DR

This study uses deep near-infrared HST imaging of globular cluster M4 to identify potential brown dwarf candidates by analyzing the color-magnitude diagram and proper-motion data, reaching beyond the hydrogen-burning limit.

Contribution

It provides the deepest NIR CMD of a globular cluster to date and identifies four promising brown dwarf candidates using combined optical and NIR data.

Findings

Reached beyond the hydrogen-burning limit in NIR CMDs.

Identified four strong brown dwarf candidates.

Demonstrated the effectiveness of combined optical-NIR analysis.

Abstract

We present an analysis of deep HST/WFC3 near-IR (NIR) imaging data of the globular cluster M4. The best-photometry NIR colour-magnitude diagram (CMD) clearly shows the main sequence extending towards the expected end of the Hydrogen-burning limit and going beyond this point towards fainter sources. The white dwarf sequence can be identified. As such, this is the deepest NIR CMD of a globular cluster to date. Archival HST optical data were used for proper-motion cleaning of the CMD and for distinguishing the white dwarfs (WDs) from brown dwarf (BD) candidates. Detection limits in the NIR are around F110W approx 26.5 mag and F160W approx27 mag, and in the optical around F775W approx 28 mag. Comparing our observed CMDs with theoretical models, we conclude that we have reached beyond the H-burning limit in our NIR CMD and are probably just above or around this limit in our optical-NIR CMDs. Thus, any faint NIR sources that have no optical counterpart are potential BD candidates, since the optical data are not deep enough to detect them. We visually inspected the positions of NIR sources which are fainter than the H-burning limit in F110W and for which the optical photometry did not return a counterpart. We found in total five sources for which we did not get an optical measurement. For four of these five sources, a faint optical counterpart could be visually identified, and an upper optical magnitude was estimated. Based on these upper optical magnitude limits, we conclude that one source is likely a WD, one source could either be a WD or BD candidate, and the remaining two sources agree with being BD candidates. For only one source no optical counterpart could be detected, which makes this source a good BD candidate. We conclude that we found in total four good BD candidates.