Empirical Isochrones for Low Mass Stars in Nearby Young Associations

TL;DR

This study constructs empirical isochrones for low-mass stars in nearby young associations, compares them with models, and proposes a simple empirical method for ordering clusters by luminosity, revealing discrepancies in age estimates.

Contribution

It provides empirical isochrones for young stellar groups and evaluates the accuracy of theoretical models, improving age estimation methods for low-mass stars.

Findings

Improved models show better agreement with empirical isochrones.

Empirical methods can order clusters with reduced spectral type dependence.

Age estimates suggest younger ages for low-mass stars than some previous estimates.

Abstract

Absolute ages of young stars are important for many issues in pre-main sequence stellar and circumstellar evolution but are long recognized as difficult to derive and calibrate. In this paper, we use literature spectral types and photometry to construct empirical isochrones in HR diagrams for low-mass stars and brown dwarfs in the eta Cha, epsilon Cha, and TW Hya Associations and the beta Pic and Tuc-Hor Moving Groups. A successful theory of pre-main sequence evolution should match the shapes of the stellar loci for these groups of young stars. However, when comparing the combined empirical isochrones to isochrones predicted from evolutionary models, discrepancies lead to a spectral type (mass) dependence in stellar age estimates. Improved prescriptions for convection and boundary conditions in the latest models of pre-main sequence models lead to a significantly improved correspondence between empirical and model isochrones, with small offsets at low temperatures that may be explained by observational uncertainties or by model limitations. Independent of model predictions, linear fits to combined stellar loci of these regions provide a simple empirical method to order clusters by luminosity with a reduced dependence on spectral type. Age estimates calculated from various sets of modern models that reproduce Li depletion boundary ages of the beta Pic Moving Group also imply a ~4 Myr age for the low mass members of the Upper Sco OB Association, which is younger than the 11 Myr age that has been recently estimated for intermediate mass members.