The consistency test on the cosmic evolution

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new method to test the consistency of cosmic evolution models by comparing ratios derived from CMB, SN Ia, and BAO data, confirming current models are consistent within uncertainties.

Contribution

It develops a robust, model-independent test for cosmic evolution consistency using combined observational data from CMB, SN Ia, and BAO measurements.

Findings

The test confirms consistency of Lambda-CDM and wCDM models with current data within 1-sigma CL.

Current data sets show good agreement between CMB, SN Ia, and BAO measurements.

Future surveys will improve constraints and test the models more stringently.

Abstract

We propose a new and robust method to test the consistency of the cosmic evolution given by a cosmological model. It is realized by comparing the combined quantity r_d^CMB/D_V^SN, which is derived from the comoving sound horizon r_d from cosmic microwave background (CMB) measurements and the effective distance D_V derived from low-redshift Type-Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) data, with direct and independent r_d/D_V obtained by baryon acoustic oscillation (BAO) measurements at median redshifts. We apply this test method for the Lambda-CDM and wCDM models, and investigate the consistency of the derived value of r_d/D_V from Planck 2015 and the SN Ia data sets of Union2.1 and JLA (z<1.5), and the r_d/D_V directly given by BAO data from six-degree-field galaxy survey (6dFGS), Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 7 Main Galaxy Survey (SDSS-DR7 MGS), DR11 of SDSS-III, WiggleZ and Ly-alpha forecast surveys from Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Data (BOSS) DR-11 over 0.1<z<2.36. We find that r_d^CMB/D_V^SN for both non-flat Lambda-CDM and flat wCDM models with Union2.1 and JLA data are well consistent with the BAO and CMB measurements within 1-sigma CL. Future surveys will further tight up the constraints significantly, and provide stronger test on the consistency.