Testing eccentricity pumping mechanisms to model eccentric long period sdB binaries with MESA

TL;DR

This study extends the MESA stellar evolution code to include eccentricity-pumping mechanisms, aiming to explain observed eccentric long-period sdB binaries, and tests their effects on binary evolution models.

Contribution

The paper introduces new implementations of eccentricity-pumping processes in MESA and evaluates their impact on modeling eccentric sdB binary systems.

Findings

Tidally-enhanced wind mass-loss can produce eccentric models but results in too light helium white dwarfs.

Phase-dependent RLOF can reintroduce eccentricity during mass transfer.

Combining RLOF with circumbinary disk interactions increases eccentricity, but models still mismatch observed period-eccentricity trends.

Abstract

Hot subdwarf-B stars in long-period binaries are found to be on eccentric orbits, even though current binary-evolution theory predicts those objects to be circularised before the onset of Roche-lobe overflow (RLOF). We aim to find binary-evolution mechanisms that can explain these eccentric long-period orbits, and reproduce the currently observed period-eccentricity diagram. Three different processes are considered; tidally-enhanced wind mass-loss, phase-dependent RLOF on eccentric orbits and the interaction between a circumbinary disk and the binary. The binary module of the stellar-evolution code MESA (Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics) is extended to include the eccentricity-pumping processes. The effects of different input parameters on the final period and eccentricity of a binary-evolution model are tested with MESA. The end products of models with only tidally-enhanced wind mass-loss can indeed be eccentric, but these models need to lose too much mass, and invariably end up with a helium white dwarf that is too light to ignite helium. Within the tested parameter space, no sdBs in eccentric systems are formed. Phase-dependent RLOF can reintroduce eccentricity during RLOF, and could help to populate the short-period part of the period-eccentricity diagram. When phase-dependent RLOF is combined with eccentricity pumping via a circumbinary disk, the higher eccentricities can be reached as well. A remaining problem is that these models favour a distribution of higher eccentricities at lower periods, while the observed systems show the opposite. The models presented here are potentially capable of explaining the period-eccentricity distribution of long-period sdB binaries, but further theoretical work on the physical mechanisms is necessary.