Meridional Flow in the Solar Convection Zone II: Helioseismic Inversions of GONG Data

TL;DR

This study uses helioseismic inversions of GONG data to analyze the solar meridional flow, confirming some recent findings but also highlighting challenges in mass conservation and measurement accuracy.

Contribution

It provides a comprehensive helioseismic analysis of meridional flow using GONG data, validating methods on artificial data and comparing results with other datasets.

Findings

Poleward flows observed at all latitudes

Shallow equatorward flow at 65 Mm depth

Mass flux conservation issues identified

Abstract

Meridional flow is thought to play a very important role in the dynamics of the solar convection zone; however, because of its relatively small amplitude, precisely measuring it poses a significant challenge. Here we present a complete time-distance helioseismic analysis of about two years of ground-based GONG Doppler data to retrieve the meridional circulation profile for modest latitudes, in an attempt to corroborate results from other studies. We use an empirical correction to the travel times due to an unknown center-to-limb systematic effect. The helioseismic inversion procedure is first tested and reasonably validated on artificial data from a large-scale numerical simulation, followed by a test to broadly recover the solar differential rotation found from global seismology. From GONG data, we measure poleward photospheric flows at all latitudes with properties that are comparable with earlier studies, and a shallow equatorward flow about $65$\,Mm beneath the surface, in agreement with recent findings from HMI data. No strong evidence of multiple circulation cells in depth nor latitude is found, yet the whole phase space has not yet been explored. Tests of mass flux conservation are then carried out on the inferred GONG and HMI flows and compared to a fiducial numerical baseline from models, and we find that the continuity equation is poorly satisfied. While the two disparate data sets do give similar results for about the outer $15\%$ of the interior radius, the total inverted circulation pattern appears to be unphysical in terms of mass conservation when interpreted over modest time scales. We can likely attribute this to both the influence of realization noise and subtle effects in the data and measurement procedure.