Thermodynamic work from operational principles

TL;DR

This paper develops a general, axiomatic framework for defining and quantifying work in quantum thermodynamics, extending beyond traditional models and deriving fundamental thermodynamic principles from operational assumptions.

Contribution

It introduces a novel approach to defining work as a resource quantifier through operational axioms, avoiding primitive definitions and deriving key thermodynamic laws.

Findings

Derives a quantitative second law bounding work extraction from non-equilibrium resources.

Establishes a formal connection between reversibility, correlations, and the second law.

Recovers the classical energy-based notion of work as a special case within the formalism.

Abstract

In recent years we have witnessed a concentrated effort to make sense of thermodynamics for small-scale systems. One of the main difficulties is to capture a suitable notion of work that models realistically the purpose of quantum machines, in an analogous way to the role played, for macroscopic machines, by the energy stored in the idealisation of a lifted weight. Despite of several attempts to resolve this issue by putting forward specific models, these are far from capturing realistically the transitions that a quantum machine is expected to perform. In this work, we adopt a novel strategy by considering arbitrary kinds of systems that one can attach to a quantum thermal machine and seeking for work quantifiers. These are functions that measure the value of a transition and generalise the concept of work beyond the model of a lifted weight. We do so by imposing simple operational axioms that any reasonable work quantifier must fulfil and by deriving from them stringent mathematical condition with a clear physical interpretation. Our approach allows us to derive much of the structure of the theory of thermodynamics without taking as a primitive the definition of work. We can derive, for any work quantifier, a quantitative second law in the sense of bounding the work that can be performed using some non-equilibrium resource by the work that is needed to create it. We also discuss in detail the role of reversibility and correlations in connection with the second law. Furthermore, we recover the usual identification of work with energy in degrees of freedom with vanishing entropy as a particular case of our formalism. Our mathematical results can be formulated abstractly and are general enough to carry over to other resource theories than quantum thermodynamics.