Difference image analysis: The interplay between the photometric scale factor and systematic photometric errors

TL;DR

This paper analyzes how errors in the photometric scale factor affect the accuracy of difference image analysis (DIA) photometry, emphasizing the need to minimize such errors to reduce systematic inaccuracies.

Contribution

It derives an expression for propagating errors in DIA, highlighting the significance of the photometric scale factor's accuracy, which is often overlooked in current surveys.

Findings

Errors in the photometric scale factor significantly impact DIA photometry.

Neglecting scale factor errors can lead to systematic photometric inaccuracies.

Minimizing or correcting scale factor errors is essential for reliable DIA results.

Abstract

Context: Understanding the source of systematic errors in photometry is essential for their calibration. Aims: We investigate how photometry performed on difference images can be influenced by errors in the photometric scale factor. Methods: We explore the equations for difference image analysis (DIA) and we derive an expression describing how errors in the difference flux, the photometric scale factor and the reference flux are propagated to the object photometry. Results: We find that the error in the photometric scale factor is important, and while a few studies have shown that it can be at a significant level, it is currently neglected by the vast majority of photometric surveys employing DIA. Conclusions: Minimising the error in the photometric scale factor, or compensating for it in a post-calibration model, is crucial for reducing the systematic errors in DIA photometry.