On Separate Universes

TL;DR

This paper proves the separate universe conjecture for certain density perturbations in $\\Lambda$CDM, generalizes it to scalar perturbations, and clarifies the implications for local non-Gaussianity and galaxy bias measurements.

Contribution

It provides a rigorous proof of the separate universe conjecture for spherical and general scalar perturbations, and clarifies the observational signatures of non-Gaussianity.

Findings

The separate universe conjecture holds for spherical compensated tophat perturbations.

The conjecture extends to scalar perturbations' isotropic part but not anisotropic parts.

Nonlinear gravitational dynamics do not produce observable local-type non-Gaussianity signals.

Abstract

(abridged version) The separate universe conjecture states that in General Relativity a density perturbation behaves locally (i.e. on scales much smaller than the wavelength of the mode) as a separate universe with different background density and curvature. We prove this conjecture for a spherical compensated tophat density perturbation of arbitrary amplitude and radius in $\Lambda$CDM. We then use Conformal Fermi Coordinates to generalize this result to scalar perturbations of arbitrary configuration and scale. In this case, the separate universe conjecture holds for the isotropic part of the perturbations. The anisotropic part on the other hand is exactly captured by a tidal field in the Newtonian form. We show that the separate universe picture is restricted to scales larger than the sound horizons of all fluid components. We then derive an expression for the locally measured matter bispectrum induced by a long-wavelength mode of arbitrary wavelength. We show that nonlinear gravitational dynamics does not generate observable contributions that scale like local-type non-Gaussianity $f_{\rm NL}^{\rm loc}$, and hence does not contribute to a scale-dependent galaxy bias $\Delta b \propto k^{-2}$ on large scales; rather, the locally measurable long-short mode coupling assumes a form essentially identical to subhorizon perturbation theory results, once the long-mode density perturbation is replaced by the synchronous-comoving gauge density perturbation. Apparent $f_{\rm NL}^{\rm loc}$-type contributions arise through projection effects on photon propagation, which depend on the specific large-scale structure tracer and observable considered, and are in principle distinguishable from the local mode coupling induced by gravity. We conclude that any observation of $f_{\rm NL}^{\rm loc}$ beyond these projection effects signals a departure from standard single-clock inflation.