Is the Low-Complexity Mobile-Relay-Aided FFR-DAS Capable of Outperforming the High-Complexity CoMP?

TL;DR

This paper compares low-complexity MR-FFR-DAS and high-complexity CoMP-CAS systems, showing that under certain conditions, the simpler MR-FFR-DAS with SC-PDA receiver can outperform CoMP-CAS in cell-edge performance.

Contribution

It demonstrates that a low-complexity MR-FFR-DAS with SC-PDA can surpass CoMP-CAS in cell-edge performance under low transmission power and optimized relay placement.

Findings

MR-FFR-DAS has lower inherent spatial diversity than CoMP-CAS.

MR-FFR-DAS with SC-PDA outperforms CoMP-CAS at moderate MS transmit power.

Power control and relay positioning enhance cell-edge performance and fairness.

Abstract

Coordinated multi-point transmission/reception aided collocated antenna system (CoMP-CAS) and mobile relay assisted fractional frequency reuse distributed antenna system (MR-FFR-DAS) constitute a pair of virtual-MIMO based technical options for achieving high spectral efficiency in interference-limited cellular networks. In practice both techniques have their respective pros and cons, which are studied in this paper by evaluating the achievable cell-edge performance on the uplink of multicell systems. We show that assuming the same antenna configuration in both networks, the maximum available cooperative spatial diversity inherent in the MR-FFR-DAS is lower than that of the CoMP-CAS. However, when the cell-edge MSs have a low transmission power, the lower-complexity MR-FFR-DAS relying on the simple single-cell processing may outperform the CoMP-CAS by using the proposed soft-combining based probabilistic data association (SC-PDA) receiver, despite the fact that the latter scheme is more complex and incurs a higher cooperation overhead. Furthermore, the benefits of the SC-PDA receiver may be enhanced by properly selecting the MRs' positions. Additionally, we show that the performance of the cell-edge MSs roaming near the angular direction halfway between two adjacent RAs (i.e. the "worst-case direction") of the MR-FFR-DAS may be more significantly improved than that of the cell-edge MSs of other directions by using multiuser power control, which also improves the fairness amongst cell-edge MSs. Our simulation results show that given a moderate MS transmit power, the proposed MR-FFR-DAS architecture employing the SC-PDA receiver is capable of achieving significantly better bit-error rate (BER) and effective throughput across the entire cell-edge area, including even the "worst-case direction" and the cell-edge boundary, than the CoMP-CAS architecture.