Zonal Flows and Turbulence in Fluids and Plasmas

TL;DR

This paper investigates how turbulence transitions to zonal flows in fluids and plasmas, using the CE2 framework to analyze symmetry-breaking instabilities and pattern formation, revealing multiple stable flow wavelengths and jet merging dynamics.

Contribution

It extends the understanding of zonostrophic instability within the CE2 framework, linking it to pattern formation theory and analyzing the stability of zonal flow wavelengths.

Findings

Zonostrophic instability can be viewed as a pattern formation process.

Multiple zonal flow wavelengths are possible, with only a subset being stable.

Unstable wavelengths evolve through jet merging to reach stability.

Abstract

In geophysical and plasma contexts, zonal flows are well known to arise out of turbulence. We elucidate the transition from statistically homogeneous turbulence without zonal flows to statistically inhomogeneous turbulence with steady zonal flows. Starting from the Hasegawa--Mima equation, we employ both the quasilinear approximation and a statistical average, which retains a great deal of the qualitative behavior of the full system. Within the resulting framework known as CE2, we extend recent understanding of the symmetry-breaking `zonostrophic instability'. Zonostrophic instability can be understood in a very general way as the instability of some turbulent background spectrum to a zonally symmetric coherent mode. As a special case, the background spectrum can consist of only a single mode. We find that in this case the dispersion relation of zonostrophic instability from the CE2 formalism reduces exactly to that of the 4-mode truncation of generalized modulational instability. We then show that zonal flows constitute pattern formation amid a turbulent bath. Zonostrophic instability is an example of a Type I$_s$ instability of pattern-forming systems. The broken symmetry is statistical homogeneity. Near the bifurcation point, the slow dynamics of CE2 are governed by a well-known amplitude equation, the real Ginzburg-Landau equation. The important features of this amplitude equation, and therefore of the CE2 system, are multiple. First, the zonal flow wavelength is not unique. In an idealized, infinite system, there is a continuous band of zonal flow wavelengths that allow a nonlinear equilibrium. Second, of these wavelengths, only those within a smaller subband are stable. Unstable wavelengths must evolve to reach a stable wavelength; this process manifests as merging jets. These behaviors ...