Classification of Charge Density Waves Based on Their Nature

TL;DR

This paper challenges traditional views by demonstrating that the momentum dependence of electron-phonon coupling, rather than Fermi surface nesting, primarily determines the origin of charge density waves in certain materials, using experimental data from 2H-NbSe2.

Contribution

It introduces a method to extract the electron-phonon coupling matrix element from combined electronic and phononic measurements, redefining the understanding of CDW formation.

Findings

EPC matrix element, not FSN, explains CDW origin in 2H-NbSe2.

Large EPC does not necessarily cause CDW, as shown in Bi2212.

Charge order in cuprates is not driven by FSN or EPC.

Abstract

The concept of a Charge Density Wave (CDW) permeates much of condensed matter physics and chemistry. Conceptually, CDWs have their origin rooted in the instability of a one-dimensional system described by Peierls. The extension of this concept to reduced dimensional systems has led to the concept of Fermi surface nesting (FSN), which dictates the wave vector q_cdw of the CDW and the corresponding lattice distortion. The idea is that segments of the Fermi contours are connected by q_cdw, resulting in the effective screening of phonons inducing Kohn Anomalies in their dispersion at q_cdw, driving a lattice restructuring at low temperatures. There is growing theoretical and experimental evidence that this picture fails in many real systems and in fact it is the momentum dependence of the electron-phonon coupling (EPC) matrix element that determines the characteristic of CDW phase (q_cdw). Here, based on the published results for the prototypical CDW system 2H-NbSe2, we show how well the q-dependent EPC matrix element, but not the FSN, can describe the origin of CDW. We further demonstrate a procedure of combing electronic band and phonon (dispersion and linewidth) measurements to extract the EPC matrix element, allowing the electronic states involved in the EPC to be identified. Thus we show that a large EPC does not necessarily induce the CDW phase, with Bi2Sr2CaCu2O8 (Bi2212) as the example, and the charge ordered phenomena observed in various cuprates are not driven by FSN or EPC. To experimentally resolve the microscopic picture of EPC will lead to a fundamental change in the way we think about, write about, and classify Charge Density Waves.