Crossover of the pairing symmetry from $s$- to $d$-wave in iron pnictide superconductors

TL;DR

This study reveals a doping-induced transition from s-wave to d-wave pairing symmetry in iron pnictide superconductors, with an intermediate s± state at the crossover, clarifying the evolution of the superconducting order parameter.

Contribution

It demonstrates the doping-driven crossover of pairing symmetry from s++ to d-wave, including the identification of an intermediate s± state in BaFe₂₋ₓNiₓAs₂ superconductors.

Findings

Evidence for two-band s-wave order at x<0.15

Line nodes in the superconducting gap for x>0.15

Identification of an intermediate s± state at the crossover

Abstract

One of the major themes in the physics of condensed matter is unconventional superconductivity in correlated electronic systems. The symmetry structure of Cooper pairs is thought to be the key to the understanding of the pairing mechanism of their superconductivity. In iron pnictide superconductors, the precise symmetry of the order parameter as well its evolution with doping remains highly controversial. There is no general consensus on the nature of pairing in iron-based superconductors leaving the perspectives ranging from $s^{++}$ wave, to $s^{\pm}$, and $d$ wave. Here we show that doping induced a sudden change of the pairing symmetry from the $s^{++}$- to $d$-wave in the BaFe$_{2-x}$Ni$_{x}$As$_{2}$ system with an $s^{\pm}$ state near the crossover boundary at $x=0.15$. The presence of the $s^{\pm}$ state is of particular scientific interest because an intermediate phase breaks the pairing symmetry when the $s$- and $d$-wave phases come together to interfere. For $x <$ 0.15, the temperature dependence of the London penetration depth, lower critical field, and specific heat in the superconducting (SC) state provides strong evidence for a two-band $s$-wave order parameter. Upon doping for $x >$ 0.15, we find the temperature and magnetic-field contributions to the specific heat in $T^{2}$ and $\sqrt{H}$, respectively, indicating line nodes in the SC gap. These findings thus clarify the symmetry nature as well as the evolution of the SC order parameter with doping in pnictide superconductors.